Kelly's Inn

The food is good and service was great. We had no idea there were still restaurants you can smoke in though. The entire place was full of smoke and smelled worse with years of smoking. Not our cup of tea...

I attend a conference that has been in York, PA for several years now. About 10 years or so ago I discovered Kelly's when I was looking to see if anywhere in York had Blue Crabs. We've been going each year ever since (except for the past 2 since the conference didn't happen in 2020 and I didn't attend in 2021). The crabs are always fabulous. You can get half dozens as well as dozens. The prices seem in line with what I would expect (it's market price.). I usually get the spinach salad with WARM bacon dressing that is always tasty. My friends are normally very pleased with their meals. There are two sides. The lounge side and the restaurant side. The lounge side opens earlier but allows smoking and you must be 21+ to be in there. The restaurant opens at 4PM (3PM on Sunday)

The place is dark, smoking in bar,Could have a makeover! I asked for 4 different kinds of drink. The waitressCouldn't make it. The drinks are reasonably priced. The menu is not large. Everyone seems to like their seafood. The price is $15-$24. I hada crab cake sandwich basket not bad. The tables need replaced. Our table had holes in the table that people dug out! The service was good. People seem to like the place. I would not go back. Place seemed greasy.

Kelly's Inn in York, PA. I'm afraid to touch anything! The chairs are split and the place is dinghy and old but the waitress is friendly and the room is warm, except near the window. ;)We had the Maryland crab soup and the creamy Maryland crab soup. Neither were hot. The creamy one was bland and the other had just shreds of crab and more of a vegetable flavor. The Harvest Mill crackers were very good. Skip the stuffed potato. It was small and bland and lukewarm. The fries would have been better if they were served hot. The winner of the evening was the fish - hot and tasty! Kelly's is so close we may come back. Just for drinks.

Kellys Inn has some of the best seafood in town, at the best price. Our only gripe is that occasionally they're understaffed (even before the pandemic). Still, Kellys Inn remains one of our favorite places for date night. I didn't see our favorite broiled oyster appetizer last time we dined there but hopefully it returns to the menu -- we used to order double helpings, they were so absolutely wonderful.

Great crabs, great service- this is where we stop on the way to Orioles games. One side is a nice seafood restaurant the other a bar

Sat in the bar, Denise is our bartender. She makes awesome Bloody Mary's!! Had something new called Hoop Tea, better than Mike's!! Food was great! We had the fried chicken and crab cake!!! AwesomeCrabs are popular here! IF YOU WANT CRABS ORDER AHEAD!!!!!

Favorite bar, hope I'm welcome again soon. Beers cold, ash trays plentiful. Jack fire always on deck

Unfortunately, the two nights in a row that we went into this restaurant they had "run out of crabs". The second day we had called earlier in the day and they had medium and large crabs available but when we arrived we were told that they were sold out....again. It would have been nice from them to let us know on either of the days that a reservation for crabs was needed to actually eat crabs in a crab establishment.

Hard shells are great. Friendly staff. Bar atmosphere, no frills, just good food. Yummy!