Fishery Seafood Market

After peeping the almost five-star rating, I had to check this fish market out! Sheesh! I thought the fresh seafood at Whole Foods Market was overpriced. Welp, the Fishery Seafood Market takes the cake and then some! After walking in and seeing the price of their cocktail shrimp, it was hell to the naw! Pay $19.99 per pound for cocktail shrimp? No way on God's green earth! Made a beeline to Safeway a few blocks away and got the same cocktail shrimp on sale (with my Safeway Club Card) for $10.99 per pound. Doesn't take a genius to see that I made out like a fat cat!Anyhoo, hate to be the bearer of bad news, but I spotted more "sticker shock" at the Fishery Seafood Market. Hold on to your seat for this! Fresh salmon at $23 per pound? So called "jumbo" crab cakes that are smaller than the palm of my hand at $13.99 each? Hmmm...On a good note, the interior of the market is clean and well-organized. Shelves are filled to the brim with various seasonings, cooking oils, fresh produce, and other grocery items. Beware: More "sticker shock", y'all! The asking price for a small container of Old Bay Seasoning is close to $7. Got the same size of said seasoning at the Safeway for $3.99. Hmmm...Verdict? Won't be back anytime soon. A little too pricey for my blood. We're talking bougie level here! Gotta have deep pockets to shop at the Fishery Seafood Market, y'all!

During lent we observe the no meat Friday tradition in the Catholic Church. As carnivores, that is a bit of a challenge for us. This year we found this market and it has gone really well for us, especially since they have several pre-cooked items so you don't have to do much preparation. So far we have tried the pre-cooked cocktail shrimp with their sauce and have found it super fresh and really good. The white fish salad was too salty for me but generally okay. My wife has gotten oysters, crab meat, lobster, and sardines. All were great. The prices are on the high side but the quality is way better than a safeway or giant and I think even better than whole foods. So if you can afford a little more to get better quality (I know that can be tough these days) I would recommend checking this place out.

Some might criticize the pricing at this store, but those that know quality premium never frozen seafood will know this is the place to go! For example, Almost all grocery store seafood markets take frozen shrimp and thaw them for display in the display case so you think it is fresh.You get what you pay for, so if you are seeking best value (units of happiness per dollar spent) this is my top choice!Gary F

Just go. Walk in the store and find not only seafood and fish delights; but, many gourmet accompanying items to make your meal most memorable.

Just moved from the northeast where fish was plentiful and easy to buy. This place is super expensive for what they have. While it was vice nice inside and does not smell like fish, the prices were a bit of a shock for what it was. Given the parking I may go to Whole Foods next time as it's closer and I'll pay a little less.

Hate to write a bad review for a small independently owned business. But last two times bought so-called fresh fish that tasted like cardboard. Threw most of it out. No way it had not been frozen! And at a price that rivalled Blacksalt. For example, their local rockfish was over $32 per pound, at the Giant the same day was $14.99. I mean this in a constructive way-- they need to pay attention to: 1. Quality and 2. Pricing.

The freshest fish, best quality in town and with very competitive prices. And the market always has every, single thing I need including produce, pasta, olive oil, pantry items, ice cream and Asian specialities. Very friendly staff. Highly recommend.

Excellent selection of fresh fish and well-curated, high quality products like pastas, sauces, pantry items, treats, and more in a clean and friendly shop!

We love this place. folks who know fish, the difference between farm raise and wild will understand the price difference. they alway have whole fish from which they will cut you however much you need. Unlike Whole Foods where the price far outweighs the quality here the fish is worth every penny. And the owners and employees are so polite. Sometimes I will also buy vegetables which are fresh and other gourmet items. But we go for the fish.Sangeeta

I moved to town in the summer of 2021 and am thrilled to have discovered the Fishery Seafood Market. The quality of the fish here is outstanding. It is way better than Giant and Whole Foods... there is no comparison. I would also argue with some of the other posts here that it is really expensive but it is most definitely not more expensive than Whole Foods if you consider the quality. My husband and I eat a lot of fish and this is now my go-to spot!