Benny’s

Incredible doesn't even begin to describe how delicious the food at Benny's is. My friend and I decided to try Benny's new place. We used to frequent Joe Benny's before he closed so we knew it was going to be good. Benny's did not disappoint.We split the blackened chicken Caesar wings. They were so juicy, perfectly cooked, and the flavor was amazing. I had the pistachio cream rigatoni. Again, the flavor is just amazing. You get a very large portion. My friend got the caprese sub. It definitely was a big ass sub. Per my friend, it could have used a protein like chicken, prosciutto or maybe salami.For dessert, we split the tiramisu panna cotta. Great flavor and texture. Big portion. Overall, amazing food, incredible service. Tony, our server, was friendly, attentive, and provided great recommendations.I will definitely be coming back to try more!!

Located near the heart of Little Italy, Benny's seems to be a local Italian favorite and it certainly has the look and feel of one.I never made it past the bar so I can't speak for the rest of the interior, but the patrons at the bar certainly seemed like locals and reggies (regulars) - they were talkative with the staff and with each other. The bar scene is friendly and boisterous without being too loud. Tried and hungry, I just wanted to enjoy some good Italian food while having a glass of wine and watching the game.I kick myself for not trying the meatballs given everyone else's review, but sometimes my head overpowers my stomach. I wanted meatballs, but my head was telling me to try something unique that I couldn't try too many other places. So, I opted for the pistachio cream pasta. This dish may go over better with someone who likes creamy pastas and onions - I am not one of those. For me, it felt heavy. I appreciated the unique offering, but if I came back, I'd try the meatballs. The Caesar salad was fine as a starter, but nothing to write home about.If you're staying near the Inner Harbor, Benny's is a fine option if you're looking for a local, friendly scene with some quality Italian food.

Food: 5Service: 5Ambiance: 4They're not lying when they say "best balls on the block". Probably the best meatballs I've ever had- juicy and flavorful with some really good marinara and cheese.The pistachio rigatoni was creamy, nutty, perfectly al dente just chef's kiss! Never had pistachio pasta before but now I'll always be looking for that on a menu. Excited to try their focaccia next time (they were all sold out on a Sunday night). Servers were very attentive and always topped off our waters despite it being a pretty busy dinner time. They checked in on us a good amount.We sat in the bar area because the dining room was packed so it definitely was not your typical Italian restaurant vibes. But, it was still cozy and felt like familial neighborhood bar.

Benny's really came back with a bang!! Shared a bunch of apps and food with some friends and everything was DELISH! Best part was the half off wines! The focaccia pizza was amazing, the eggplant meatballs were so juicy and tender, the stuffed peppers were DIVINE (that pink sauce!!!) and the salad was so fresh! The service was great - food came out so quickly! They were out of the tiramisu so we got the cream puffs and they were yummy! Need to come back to try more!!

We were welcomed when we arrived and shown to a table just perfect for the toddler and 38wk pregnant mom in our party. We wanted to sample some good food and EVERYTHING we ordered was fantastic! Meatballs, calamari, braciole, focaccia, seafood linguine. Too much to finish but it's still good when reheated. The service at home is less attentive than in the restaurant though. I can't wait to come back and try some more food... and reunite with my family from another mother.

The new restaurant has retained the charm - and tastiness - of the old Joe Bennys, but in a more upscale environment, and with an expanded menu. The focaccia was excellent, as always - dense and packed with flavor, and the meatballs are still the best on the block (or possibly any block). They also have a vegetarian version made of eggplant, which were very enjoyable. A new favorite is the pistachio pasta, which was unique and creamy without being heavy or overwhelming. This is a great addition to the neighborhood and a true gem of a dining experience.

Lived up to the hype. Their meatballs are amazing. Great vibes too. Will be back to try their pasta next time.

Our first time at the new Benny's and it was great. Good food, nice ambiance, and helpful wait staff. A nice 70th birthday dinner. We will definitely return.

Super fun place with amazing meatballs. Everyone was super friendly with lots of regulars who all the staff seemed to know by name.

My new found city restaurant! The meatballs and the gnocchi were outstanding. Don't skip the Focaccia. Excellent service!