Buffalo Chicken Pizza Pie
food, pizza
More bottles
08-15-22
View of the bar
Created my own little tasting
Bottles
Everything you can imagine + small batch + barrel select
Paloma & Salted Carmel martini... so good!
Decor
Old fashion
Inside
Cocktails!
Inside
Wonderful selection of bourbons
Nostalgia
Nostalgic decor
Welcoming atmosphere
a pizza in a box
The magical gold sauce!!!
Veggies and ranch - so fresh!
Menu
Sausage Pizza Pie
Gina A.
Jan 12, 2025
A must go if you enjoy amazing pizza. This is a gem of a place. The best pizza. They are personal sized although 2 people could easily share one. They have an extensive selection of flavors. We tried the meat, the everything, and the shrimp fra diavolo (most favorite) and every single one was delicious. The crust is so light and airy and the toppings are just the perfect blend that brings it all together. They even have special pizza of the month that offer some very clever and tasty combinations.Please BEWARE - you will become addicted to the magical gold sauce that they serve with their pizzas! Do not, I repeat, do not skip this important condiment for dipping the above mentioned pizza!!! You will want to drink this stuff.Barflys also has amazing salads, wings and other great treats. They also offer additional protein on top of the salads. The wings are not fried and are very tasty. The pretzel bites are delicious.They have a massive bourbon collection (this is a pizza & bourbon bar). The options are endless. They also serve seasonal cocktails, as well as beer on tap and in cans. There's even a retail section for their bourbons, etc. They can make most any drink. The espresso martinis are fantastic, especially the salted caramel one! The staff is very attentive and friendly. This is for sure your neighborhood hangout and it is always busy. It has lots of sports related decor. There is ample seating at tables, high tops, and the bar itself. Parking can be an issue since it's in the city, but seriously keep looking for a spot as you will not be disappointed.Whatever you do, grab an extra pizza to take to go!!!
Read More
Christopher G.
Oct 21, 2024
Barfly's is always a go-to when I'm in Baltimore! When you first enter, it looks like any other bar: a long bar with enough stools, tvs to watch the game, and some bar extra bar tables to additional seating. I can see this place getting packed on game days. Oh, and a nice looking wall of liquor bottles. If you love whiskey, this is definitely a spot you want to check out! Prices are pretty competitive with the market, and they have several barrel picks to choose from. They also have a pretty big tequila selection as well. If liquor isn't your thing, then go in for one of their amazing pizzas!The pizzas are the size of personal pizzas, so my wife and I will usually split whatever is the Pizza of the Week and a Buffalo Chicken Pizza, which is our favorite from here. They definitely have one of the better Buffalo Chicken Pizzas that we've had. Generous pieces of chicken and bacon throughout, with just enough buffalo sauce and blended cheeses to not over power the entire pizza. It all works so well together!The staff is friendly and the service is fairly quick. Parking may be a little difficult due to the location, but it's definitely worth it.
Read More
Shawnte W.
Dec 21, 2024
They know pizza! Visited after attending a show in the area. The place is located in a popular area of town and parking is definitely a challenge but the place itself wasn't packed at all. Nice bar vibe, clean and minimal decor. We were able to sit in the back comfortably and had no issues with service. The drinks were good and the pizza was absolutely delicious! Fresh ingredients, came out piping out and had great flavor. Would definitely visit again!
Read More
Lennea B.
Jul 14, 2024
I love it here. The pizza is amazing.My drink was tasty and they have the most bourbons to choose from in the area .The owner was our bartender and he is everything. We had great conversation and he taught us a lot about bourbon and rye ... the different companies. Nice sized bar and I found a parking spot in front. I will be returning for a cocktail and wings and pizza.
Read More
Matthew H.
Jul 29, 2024
I had been wanting to try Barfly's for quite some time. The pizza was as good as advertised. There is also an extensive whiskey menu, featuring many of the world's best beverages. The staff is great here. It is street parking only, which we found nearby with ease. We did not like the mandatory credit card fee when paying by card. There are a lot of fees nowadays I have noticed when dining out.
Read More
Carl T.
Jun 2, 2024
We like the food here and used to go here often. The salad and pizza is really good but the last few times we have come here the service has been poor. The place is small and often it is very loud inside with patrons yelling and screaming. It's become a place where we order the food to go because it is not enjoyable to be there when it is filled with drunk people screaming. The last time we ordered carry out we picked it up and went home only to find that they messed up our order and so we had to go back and wait for them to make our order correctly. Last night I wanted to order carry out and they don't allow online ordering so I called the restaurant. A lady answered the phone and I started to order and then she just hung up the phone while I was ordering. I called back 4 times and they would not pick up the phone. So then I drove up there to see what's going on. I told the bartender that we tried to call ahead and order but the person hung up on me and we tried calling back several times. He didn't say anything in response. They don't seem to care about their business or customers so much anymore. It wasn't even busy or crowded, but there was a group in the back singing off key and screaming at the top of their lungs. We had to wait half an hour for them to make one pizza and a salad. The food was tasty but I don't think the hassle is worth it anymore. The person James who took waited on was rude and just didn't seem to give a crap. Seems like they have a new owner or new manager who is in auto pilot or burned out. Time for us to find a new place for pies. Food is 5 stars but the service is a zero at this place now.
Read More
Kelsey K.
Mar 31, 2024
Good pan pizza / thick crust. Hot and Spicy pizza is the best. Roasted wings are tasty too.
Read More
LaToya E.
Dec 3, 2023
What a great little whiskey bar!! A friend told me about it so when I was looking for a place to meet a new friend for drinks it was the first thing that came to mind!! We sat at the bar and had great service from the bartenders and with such a vast selection of whiskey I can't wait to go back! I will have to give their menu another try before I comment because I wasn't impressed, however drinks makes up for it lol. It is a tight space as it's a converted row home but it didn't feel crowded until we were trying to leave.
Read More
Brian M.
Dec 8, 2023
Cool whiskey bar in nice area w parking on the street. Pizza was good almost Chicago style, not my preference but it's good. Great selection of top tier whiskey and great service.
Read More
Kristin A.
Jan 22, 2022
I'm a visual pizza eater. You know, it has to look a certain way. It needs to sell me on the idea that it has flavor, the perfect crunch when bitten and an acceptable ingredient to crust ratio. So I definitely bookmarked this place after seeing pics. I stopped in early yesterday afternoon so parking was a breeze right on Fort Ave and getting a seat at the bar was even easier. There were just a few of us so service was quick. The only thing that gave me pause was the extensive whiskey menu. It was a little overwhelming but I powered through. Grabbed 2 oz of a rye and ordered the BBQ Chicken pizza. The pie was delicious. The crust was light and crispy yet hearty and fulfilling. And if you should get a bite of the crust that's been cooked a pinch longer, it's a party in your mouth...or maybe that was the rye. Either way...listen Yelp friends, you've done it again. You were right and I'll be back.
Read More