Shut Up And Eat It Detroit style pizza
pizza, food
Patio seating
THAT CHEESE PULL THOUGH....
Vodka sauce, sausage and pepper Detroit style pizza!
Tiki anyone?
Atmosphere
Beer selection
Master of Pigs Detroit style pizza
Funky, cool, eclectic!!!
High Top Tables
Cool spot to chill
Everyone loves pizza
Kolsch beer from the tap
JERSEY TURNPIKE
this was on the table - great read while waiting for pizza
interior
That Dole Whip & Lavender Haze
Margherita pizza
Brick-oven pizza
I am eating this with a fork & knife
BYO PIZZA (pepperoni and pineapple) & a white pizza
Jim Jones Juice
a drink on a table
Gaby T.
Sep 3, 2024
This is a great place to grab a pizza with a friend. The atmosphere is video game themed...which was really cool! It felt very chill and comfortable. The pizza was also AMAZING! The crust was crispy and cheesy, the flavors of the tangy peppers, savory vodka sauce, fatty sausage and yummy cheese just meshed so nicely together. My mouth is watering just writing this review hahah. The service was also very good! They were attentive and helped us when we were split between 2 pies. I just wish they were closer to where I live!!!
Read More
Lauren W.
Sep 15, 2024
Amazing service at this restaurant! We were greeted as soon as we walked in and sat down. Very friendly place for everyone with a relaxed vibe. Ordered a pizza with vegan cheese (a whole plant based menu!) and pepperoni, sausage, and long hots. The crust had the perfect chew and texture. Great flavor. Very happy this place exists, will be back next time I'm around. Really want to try the square pies and Detroit style!
Read More
Michaél B.
Jan 6, 2024
Pizza and alcohol? Yes please! Such a cool place. The service was great and everyone made sure we were seated as quickly as possible (even though there was a 40 minute wait), and our server was very attentive to us. For my own selfish reason I wish this place was more of a secret because it gets super busy! But that's the sign a a great spot! We ordered the BYO pizza with pepperoni and pineapple. That was seriously good pizza!! I'm not typically a fan of pizza shop pizza, but this was excellent. My daughter ordered the white pizza and of course we helped her finish it. It was so good. The drinks were very good. I love that they have a variety of beer and mixed drinks available. This is definitely a fun place where we plan to frequent whenever we are in York.
Read More
Jena B.
Jan 12, 2025
Foods good. Everytime I go and sit in here everyone around me who gets sitted way after me gets there food before me. Today, I was sat and we were the second table in the dining room, ordered right away. 3 tables proceed to get sitted around us AFTERED we ordered. How did those 3 tables get there food before me?. I didn't order alot. The same amount they did. Highly recommend just picking up
Read More
John A.
Mar 16, 2024
This very small, retro, trendy restaurant is small but fantastic. The vibe is very hipster, yet inviting to all. The seating is limited but the kitchen is shared with a brunch concept for the morning. That is connected as one unit but closed after brunch times.Most tables seat four. Some are high tops or low. Then the bar is past that and splits the restaurant to another section of tables in the back for larger parties. There is a video jute box, a pinball machine, and a video game in the back. The bathrooms were totally redone and immaculate. We ordered a beer off their extensive list. (available and live online.) There is also a paper copy but we had to ask for it.Our server was at our table very fast despite his busy section. We ordered drinks. The bar drinks took a minute but were ran by another employee. One appetizer was the Sesame Citrus Smoked Wings. Wow! Cooked perfectly. Awesome sauce. Just the right amount of smoke. Very good! 5/5We also got the Chips and Dips. The chips were fresh. Queso was rich and creamy. The guacamole was fresh and smooth. And the salsa was wonderful. Again.... 5/5We ordered a smaller round pizza called The Jersey Turnpike. It had Long Hot Peppers, sausage, pepperoni, and sauce dollops. It was thin. Was cooked perfectly. Had the perfect balance of chew and crunch. The flavor was a great balance of salty, spice, and savory. 5/5I would love to go back and try the Detroit Style Pizzas. I lived a long time in Michigan and they reminded me of Buddy's Pizza or Como's Pizza in Ferndale, MI. I love a good pizza with vodka sauce. That was from my time living in NJ. Everything from the food, the service, the drinks, and the ambience was awesome. I recommend trying to go at the beginning of a meal time. It filled up right after we got there at 5. This was also a Friday. Overall, this place is a now a top restaurant in the area for me. 5/5. Please go try this. You will be so happy that you did!
Read More
Brook B.
Nov 22, 2024
The hot honey pepperoni pizza is the SO DELICIOUS! Their smoked wings are probably the BEST wings I have ever had. 1000000000/10 recommend!
Read More
Kurt I.
Jan 6, 2024
I always want to love this place, but every other visit they really goof up the order. That's all that keeps them from being 5 stars. They always make good on it, but it can be frustrating as I'm always super specific. However, the pizza is great. Some killer vegan options, and quite delicious. If you're Autistic or have noise sensitivities like me, bring ear plugs as the noise just reverberates in there with the high ceilings and hard floors. Bottom line. Killer pizza that deviates from the norm.
Read More
Kristen O.
Mar 16, 2024
Attended an event here and they were so accommodating. The cocktails are strong and fairly priced and the apps were amazing. Love the cheese curds. The smoked chicken Detroit pizza was to die for. Wings were incredible too. Inside is smaller but super cute decor and there's a pinball machine. I can't wait to go back.
Read More
Amy G.
Sep 18, 2023
Absolutely amazing Detroit style pizza. We couldn't decide where to eat. We really weren't in the mood for pizza, but we saw this place and decided to stop. As soon as we got out of the car, we could smell the pizza and chose to give it a try.We got there pretty late but they were ok with us sitting outside and ordering some pizza. Our server was amazing. She on her own would easily earn all 5 stars for the place. Luckily, the pizza was also fabulous.We ordered two Detroit style pizzas. Each was around $20. The Master of Pigs had pulled pork, chopped brisket, bacon, BBQ sauce, and cheese. The Smoked Chicken Nightmare had smoked chicken, blackened alfredo sauce, bacon, and cheese. Both came out piping hot with the crust perfectly crispy on the bottom and fluffy on top. There were plenty of toppings so every bite combined all the flavors.Hubby tried one of the GearHouse beers (about $7) and really liked it.This was some of the best pizza I've ever eaten. I can't wait to to back. Although I'd like to try different things, I think I'll order the exact same pizza and relive the awesomeness.Our server recommend we try the pizzas with Mike's Hot Honey on the side as a dip. She was 100% correct. I had some at home and never considered using it on pizza. It's fabulous.Two thumbs way up for the pizza, the server, and the outdoor seating.
Read More
Christopher F.
Jan 10, 2025
It is literally the best pizza in the entire world. The smoked wings are amazing. The bread is made fresh and is delicious.
Read More