Anthony's New York Pizza & Pasta House
Anthony's New York Pizza & Pasta House
Pizza
New York Cheese Pizza 14"
Outside
Open area seating
Outside
Pizza Bar
Box
Pizza toppings for 14" $2.70 and 16" $2.70
Buffalo Pizza - $19.99
Cream of Crab Soup
Garlic knots 1/2 doz
Complementary bread basket and dipping oil
Pizza Meat lovers pizza 16"
Proof of purchase
Inside seating
Lemon pepper Anthony's Famous Wings 12
Anthony's Famous Wings 12
Filet Mignon, broccoli, asparagus, garlic bread
Meat lovers pizza 16"
Fried Calamari
Crab pizza
12 Piece Wings w/ Chesapeake Sauce - $14.99
Katrina F.
Jan 4, 2025
Wow, wow, wow. Can my review be just that? I guess not. The restaurant has been remodeled since my last visit. It wasn't bad before, but it is very nice now, perfect for a family dinner or date night. Service continues to be good. We were a large party (11), and the staff kept up with us. Everything was well made. The wings were on the crispier side, per our request, and well seasoned. The Cream of Crab soup was filled with crab and a good portion, enough for two to get a good taste. The main event here is the pizza. It's NY-style, with large slices and a medium/thick crust, but the edges are breadier, perfect to dip in any extra oil on the table! I am not a pizza lover, and this is honestly a too-good choice if I must eat pizza.
Read More
Rita J.
Mar 1, 2024
Great pizza and customer service at a reasonable price. The pizza's are NY style, without being in NY, if you get my drift bc you can truly only get NY style pizza IN NY! But it's a very tasty pizza. We get cheese for the non meat eaters and pepperoni for the rest and everyone is always pleased. Also, the restaurant is extremely clean which always makes my day!
Read More
Kenya G.
Aug 15, 2022
I can start by saying this was my first and last time coming to Anthony's. We ordered two 16" pizzas, 1/2 doz garlic knots and 12 wings. Sadly the pizza was just poorly prepared, way too thin in the middle it just flopped around but the crust was so thick it was hard to chew threw and in general just not very good. The grandmas pizza in theory was yummy, kind of like a margharita but it was soggy where the pizza sauce was thrown on and the buffalo chicken piZza was just bland with extremely dry and tough chicken on top. The garlic knots we were just jipped. They only gave us 3 so that was $6 or so down the drain. I don't know how to wu just serve half an order...did the staff eat the other half in the store? Ridiculous!! Lastly the wings, these wings were literally some of the worst wings I have had in a while. They were skimpy on the sauce, the wings were dry and again just bland. Overall, I do not recommend coming here since there is better pizza out here but they do have a 10% discount for teachers and first responders so that's not too bad I guess.
Read More
Dawn E.
Jan 18, 2024
One of my favorite pizza places has upped their game. They are embracing table service instead of ordering at the counter then picking a seat to wait on it. Food is great as always and there's so much more than pizza. They do have the absolute best buffalo chicken pizza though. I have not had even a close match anywhere. Sorry, no pics with this review. I'll add some when I get back there again, which I'm sure I wil!
Read More
Mark R.
Aug 22, 2024
First off its table service now. Wow very happy. Ordered the Veal Marsala, Fettuccini and pepperoni / pineapple pizza. All food was good Service was great everyone was very pleasant and happy. This was a lunch with G kids. We will be back again. It was great. Restaurant is clean and cheerful. Bathrooms were clean. Place is great for eat in lunch. As for the pics. Sorry we were mid eating when taking them. Yes it was that good.
Read More
Cody P.
Apr 22, 2022
We were staying in the area for a few weeks and found this place looking for pizza. Coming from Syracuse, NY, there weren't a lot of things foodwise we could be smug about in this area, but pizza ended up being it. So while my girlfriend spend her day hard at work, I was back at the Airbnb looking up the best pizzas for take out.Best pictures, best ratings, best menu of everything we looked at. Their menu looks great actually, it's a shame we stopped at the pizza and wings. The first time we ordered was on a Thursday. We got just a buffalo chicken pizza, and my girlfriend picked it up on her way home. We weren't expecting anything but a convenient dinner after a long day, but it ended up being the best buffalo chicken pizza we've ever had, by such a long shot. We loved the way they breaded the chicken, the sauce, the cheese, the crispy yet soft dough. The freaking celery cooked right onto it.Two days later was our last day in the area. Last call for whatever we haven't tried before we go back home. We started listed places, but our hearts weren't really into it. One of finally said "Wanna just get pizza from Anthony's again?" Hell yeah, we're done. Within an hour we had a large meat lover's and some wings, and that concluded our vacation.The meat lovers was also great, but eclipsed hard by the buffalo chicken. The wings were cooked crispy and we loved the bay seasoning flavor. The bleu cheese they had was weird, kind of sweet. We ended up using our own, which we had to get rid of anyway.In Syracuse, I feel like 15% or more of the restaurants we have are pizzerias, so it really says something that this place would still land in my top 10. It also really says something that we forewent trying a new place on our last day when our time was so limited, to instead come back and get more of what we loved from here.I'll never forget that buffalo chicken pizza.
Read More
Darryl S.
Feb 28, 2025
I order pizza and wings for take out. When I got home, the pizza was not completely cooked on the bottom. The wing order is not what I ordered. The next day, i called the store and spoke with the manager. He told me I should have called yesterday and offered 20% off my next order. I've been going to Anthony's for the past six plus years and to be told that was the best they could do? That was my last time ordering anything from them (and this is not NY pizza because pizza is not suppose to sag when you pick up a slice). This is from a true NEW YORKER!!!!
Read More
M C.
Dec 22, 2024
This is the absolute worst pizza I have ever had. They definitely need to remove the New York from the title because this isn't hardly close to New York style pizza. I would rather eat 7-Eleven pizza than to stomach this pizza again. Extremely disappointing. I hope this wasn't considered the best that MD has to offer as far as pizza goes.
Read More
Kathi W.
Nov 20, 2024
Great food and delivery. They have pasta and pizza, but their seafood dishes are good too.Crab cakes,shrimps delicious.
Read More
Paul Z.
Jan 13, 2025
Great place, great food! Always a good experience and yummy food! You can't go wrong dining here...
Read More
