Brooklyn Pie

As Italian, my pizza standards are pretty high.I have to admit that this pizza is very good!Some friends and I ordered pizza to spend the evening together and I was surprised right away!The dough was perfectly thick, and the taste was just like the one you can eat in Italy.The tomato sauce was excellent and I personally love that it wasn't mixed with garlic (which I've seen done in other places)And the cheese was not too greasy.Overall I really enjoyed it and I definitely recommend it!

Good enough pizza and salads. 3-star, average experience. It's a pick-up only, small place. You could sit next door at Little Woodrow's and grad a drink and eat. It's not exactly welcoming, they are pie slinging and kind of yell at you when you walk in as opposed to a normal "how can we help you" welcome. Order through them and pick up, so you don't get hit with the overage/fees.

Really good pizza but the toppings price on uber eats is kind of out of control. This has been my go to pizza place since i moved to south Austin and dont feel like going to homeslice.

Didn't feel like ordering our normal dominoes, and went against the 3-star reviews on this joint. So glad I did! We've actually ordered by Uber Eats and Door Dash. The first time, order was perfect. Second time, they added the wrong sauce to one of our pies. But the pizzas arrived hot, crispy, and great! I want to try eating in-store sometime, but so far we've been very happy with our deliveries. Similar to the pizzas I had in NYC.

Our pager died while we were watering so that was a bummer but incredibly helpful and nice staff. Got the fried ravioli and churro cheesecake.Fried ravioli was AMAZING. Six pieces with marinara, so delicious!Churro cheesecake was also amazing. Good size and delicious.

Pretty basic pie. The cheese is reaaaal cheesy, and well everything is just basic. Dough doesn't have too much flavor, I would say the food is more or less a filler, something to soak up the drinks you get from Little Woodrow's. I will say their buffalo wings have a bit of a kick, and are super saucy, so if thats your thing give it a go.

What a good pie... specifically a Classic New York Pizza Pie, small size (don't tease me, stuff is expensive enough nowadays!). This pizza was very good and brought back memories of the last great New York style pizza I had (which was Davinci's in Charlotte, NC). I'm not from New York and I may not know what authentic is-- but I know what I like, and this was delicious!Even the crust was nice and soft and wonderful, just like I like it. I could snack on just the crust!They forgot my request (online ordering w/Grubhub) for no sausage-- but I swear that this sausage wasn't bad at all. Very mild and nice tasting slices of sausage. This was one time that I didn't mind a mistake on my food.Based on this first experience, I will definitely be getting more Brooklyn Pie Co's pizza! It's not easy finding pizza I like here in Austin.

I ordered calzone and put request to not have any meats including pepperoni on ubereat and it's not the first time they have ignored the specific request when it comes to the allergy. glad that I did double checked and they DEFIANTLY are trying to KILLING ME for death with meats in the calzone which I didn't ask for! it's not first time happen when they do that and my suggest to go somewhere that have calzone and who does follow the request specific and not ignore the details. SHAME ON YOU!!! you could have me DEAD! if I didn't check inside the calzone!

My coworkers and I ordered Brooklyn pie for lunch and were really excited as two of my coworkers are from NY. We ordered 2 pizzas, 3 garlic knots, and 2 salads via doordash. When the food arrived, the pizzas were cold and were smooshed but tasted fine, the garlic knots were cold and unflavorful BUT we are not at the worst part- my coworkers salad that she was eating had a literal beetle CRAWLING in it!! This is absolutely disgusting and completely unacceptable. This makes me question the level of cleanliness at this business and I will never go back. See photos for reference.

Love the giant slice (and I'm from a few miles across the GW Bridge from Manhattan)! Negatives - Very little seating, opens an hour later on weekends (noon) so forget about picking up pizza before the NFL games start, and no free water.