Stumpy's New York Style Pizza

I love this place. The servers who have been here are great. They're so busy but they take time to check in when they can to chat. The pizza is the best in Castle Rock. And they have spinach! I love spinach on my pizza. The place is comfy. Lots of arcade games and the kids like it. We will keep coming here or ordering from them to go.

Excellent hidden little gem for some good NY style pizza. Wings are excellent as well. They also have pinball and a cool dark atmosphere in there if I still drank this would be my bar.

Great place! Stumpy's has a relaxed pizzeria atmosphere about it but it also has a decent bar. They have a fair few pinball machines but also a buck hunt and a claw game filled with rubber ducks for the kids. Closest thing to an arcade in Castle Rock!! There is also a pool table and a foosball! We have gone there fairly often for the past eight plus years and I have never had bad service. The staff has remained pretty consistent during that time and that says something about a place! Something good!

Pizza was good but nothing special, the service was horrible. Not enough staff! Our pizza took almost 1 hour from the time we ordered to the time we were served. Our waitress walked by several times without saying anything to us. The place itself is pretty outdated and kinda reminds me of a dive bar. It was busy for a Friday night which made the room very loud. Also, a 20% tip was automatically added to our bill even though it was just for 2 people AND service was really bad.Will not be returning as there are far better places in Castle Rock with much better pizza.

I am obsessed with the pizza here. It's probably my favorite spot in castle rock! The service can be a little slow but it's worth it to me. It's just a quality hole in the wall bar!

Great pizza and friendly waitress. Plenty to entertain kids and adults We will return

Called to place order and was quoted 25 min over the phone, and it was ready when we got there! Pretty quick for a Friday night. Good NY style thin pepperoni pizza and garlic knots. We'll come back and try one of their "fancy" pizzas in the future.

Stumpy's was able to accommodate our Company Holiday Party last week. They kept the food coming and everything was so delicious. They served my hungry and thirsty employees with speed and a smile. We all really enjoyed playing games and shooting pool. At the end of our festivities, I was surprised by how affordable it all was. I know where I will be going for my next pizza with plenty of quarters to play Galaga!Thank you Stumpy's!

Manager hired my son, had him make pizzas while he berated my son in the kitchen. After a few shifts of this my son didn't return and they never paid him for his work. They are super shady and hateful. I don't recommend supporting this business.

I love that' place good pizzas for a quick dinner the ladies very cool best pizza in town !