Deep dish 10"
Deep dish cheese (back) pepperoni regular crust (front)
Carnivore calzone
Menu p1
Chicago deep dish 10" -- actually way more than ten inches wide! Like 14"
Deep dish pizza
Menu p2 flip side
Deep dish pepperoni and sausage pizza
pizza, food
pizza, outside
Missing cheese
Some of the dining room and ambiance of the restaurant
food, pizza
$6 lunch special
pizza
food, pizza
interior
Happy Hour: 3pm-6pm. $1 off all beers and 1/2 off all appetizers.
BBQ chicken deep dish pizza
Chocolate Cake
Brownie w/ icecream scoop.
food, pizza
Not good, soggy and stale. Not restaurant quality.
Angela H.
Jan 2, 2025
Outstanding Really glad we tried itService was wonderfulWe ordered the 13" deep dish. Yummy. It does take awhile, which is good. Lou Malnatis does too
Read More
Megan P.
Mar 3, 2025
Our go to for pizza night. My husband is a Chicago native and we are so thankful to live next to such authentic deep dish. We've never dined inside, rather order online for takeout. Our favorite "toppings" are Meatball & Pepperoni. We would love to add Jalapeno but the couple of times we have there is maybe 2 tiny slivers in the whole pie; that's my only complaint. The sauce is absolutely finger licking delicious, the cheese ooey-gooey & crust cooked to perfection each time!
Read More
Elise M.
Dec 6, 2024
We were craving deep dish Chicago style pizza and nicolos did not disappoint! The pizza was fantastic and the Caesar salad wasn't bad either.
Read More
Carrie S.
Mar 11, 2024
We get deep dish delivered from Nicolos and it is absolutely delicious and always arrives hot! The crust is great, and they do not skimp on the cheese. Highly recommend the deep dish!
Read More
Kelsy E.
Jul 3, 2023
Considering I haven't tried deep dish before, I took the plunge to see what it was all about. Upon recommendation from the staff, ordered up what is like their supreme version of deep dish. Sausage, peppers, mushrooms, olives and lots of sauce. Fast, tasty, crunchy crust. Really great!
Read More
Monica L.
Apr 2, 2023
Stick to the pizza. I tried the eggplant Parmesan today. It was probably the worst eggplant Parmesan I have ever had. It appeared to be a frozen, breaded eggplant cutlet that they reheated. If they can't serve a decent eggplant Parmesan, it shouldn't be on the menu. Given how bad this was, I wouldn't trust them with anything other than pizza in the future.
Read More
Tiffany B.
Jul 16, 2023
Honestly best pizza in Highlands Ranch I love it so much. I got a small normal crust pepperoni and a small cheese deep dish both are so good and the deep dish makes great leftovers because cheese is on bottom and sauce is on top, but I can't choose which one I like more so I just get both lol. Highly recommend!
Read More
Aaron H.
Jan 20, 2025
I've been to Nicole's twice. The first time was fantastic and Ive been craving it since. On my second visit, I got the wings (great wings and Blue cheese) and the 10" Hawaiian deep dish and the 10" Four Cheese deep dish. Me and my kids were the only ones in the restaurant at 12:30 and it felt like it took a while to get the food. When the two pizza arrived, we were speechless to see two hand tossed crust pizzas. We literally sat and talked through the order process for a few minutes rehashing what we ordered and whether or not we were clear. The waiter was no where to be seen so we finally decided to just eat what we had. The service was not great on the 2nd visit and I didn't love the hand tossed pizzas. The crust was hard on the Hawaiian and the 4 cheese pizza was not great. Three stars because my first visit was so memorable but unfortunately, too many misses on the 2nd visit.
Read More
Priscilla G.
Oct 2, 2024
Yummy food.. great service! The canzone and pizza were very yummy. Our waiter Austin was very attentive and friendly
Read More
Cali F.
Mar 5, 2024
Excellent!!! Delicious deep dish!!! Yummy bread too! Great, friendly, attentive. Professional service! We highly recommend Nicolo's!
Read More