Pitmaster Sandwich
a sandwich and coleslaw
a dog sitting in front of the counter
outside
picnic tables and chairs outside
Pickles and house mild sauce, great start
Ribs
the interior of the restaurant
Watch for this sign on 24 Hwy going to Lake George, C0
a kitchen with a menu on the counter
Pitmaster
interior
Breakfast Menu
outside, sushi and sashimi
Fried pickles, pitmaster sandwich, potato salad
1/2 of the pitmaster sandwich, it was huge!
View from parking lot
Loaded baked potato with brisket
Sasuage and brisket
Potato salad
interior
Menu
pitmaster sandwich!
interior, pizza
Matt J.
Mar 1, 2025
The spicy BBQ sauce here is the best sauce I have ever had - coming from a big BBQ fan. Turkey and all of the sides were very good, highly recommend trying. Owner was also very outgoing and friendly
Read More
Carrie S.
Aug 1, 2024
We got there right when they opened so no wait at 11am on a Thursday but was getting busy by the time we left, and rightfully so!We got the pitmaster sandwich.Came with brisket, burnt ends, sausage, provolone, onions and pickles. I don't like sourdough but it was that or a wrap so we stuck with the sandwich and man of man, I wouldn't have changed a thing, it was perfect with the sourdough! The meats were all tender and full of flavor; perfect smoke and seasoning, each a little different in their own way and when served together, they were a marvelous combination. Side of that mild BBQ sauce and done! I think it was $15 and we split it and it was huge. Great first time order to try everything and I would recommend for a first visit on the road since it is not too heavy, but if up for a full meal I would try a plate next time to try even more. Brisket was tender and would love to try the ribs and maybe burnt ends on their own. I ordered the fried pickles served with ranch and they were amazing. Some of the best I ever had. The coating stayed put on the pickles and had a wonderful crunch that held up through the end of the meal. Would order them again for sure!My husband tried the potato salad and he is picky if not like his mom's and he loved it. It was tangy with a good amount of mustard but it was such a great compliment to the rich meaty sandwich, he didn't event care. I would love to try the slaw next time for that same contrast.Great food and cool quick road side stop. Nice benches and tables outside and even in a hot August day it was manageable. They look to be working on the store front portion inside so I can imagine it will only get better. Must stop on your way through town. Also cute country store across the street with amazing rice Krispy treats!
Read More
Janet D.
May 10, 2023
Really cute Bbq stop on the way home. We decided to visit Lake George after a night in the mountains. This was an accidental find. A very good one! In fact, Lake George is right across the street.We had the Ribs and the Pitmaster Sandwich. The ribs were good but the Pitmaster was the star. It's the best choice to make since it's loaded with different kinds of meat in the the menu. Sausages, brisket, burnt ends, cheese, onion and pickle. I'm a rib gal but my ribs paled in comparison to the Pitmaster I got jealous! . It's still really good though!with a side of mac and cheese. They opened in May of 2022. Their specialty is Memphis style dry rubbed ribs. Future tries: the Smoking GunThey serve breakfast burritos, breakfast bowls, biscuits and gravy with their I am sausage, homemade cinnamon rolls, a mean peach cobbler as well as espressos and lattes.Awesome service! Nice people
Read More
Chelsea H.
Sep 2, 2024
This bbq stop is amazing! The pit master is the perfect sandwich to get a variety of their meats. The brisket is done to perfection. The fried pickles and smoked wings were equally delicious. When we went there was live music too, such a great stop!
Read More
Ruthie P.
Sep 23, 2023
If you around Lake George city, stop by here for barbecue. Small town atmosphere but totally worth the stop. Very happening place and prepare for wait time. We went to the eleven mile canyon and decided to stop by here from yelp review. Good barbecue and plenty of food to fill you up. We had six in our group and everyone loved their meat selections. Very tasty. Baked beans was delicious. Mac and cheese was good. Cole slaw is good. Definitely good barbecue.
Read More
Eric R.
Sep 20, 2023
AWESOME BBQ! Off the chain. Totally out of the way, but if you happen to be passing by then don't miss this place. Some of the best BBQ I've ever had.
Read More
A. N.
Jan 17, 2024
Really good food here. Def recommend!It's in lake George, worth the stop! Cute little place!
Read More
Dawn D.
Feb 23, 2025
Excellent brisket! The sweet potato fries and fried okra were both great. Definitely worth the stop.
Read More
Danielle S.
Dec 29, 2024
amazing bbq! best we've had in colorado. very cozy feel and definitely worth the stop!
Read More
DeeAna G.
Dec 22, 2023
The food and service were amazing!! The moment we stepped in we were greeted with top notch service. I enjoyed a loaded baked potato with the most delicious brisket. My son enjoyed the Pitmaster sandwich and it was loaded and delicious. We also had a two meat plate which allowed us to tried the sausage which had such a great flavor and was so moist. As far as side goes the Mac and cheese was so cheesy, the green chili had a nice kick....the beans were epic!! All in all this place is is a must stop and this Texas girl approves!!
Read More