Antonio’s Real New York Pizza

I am a big fan of Antonio`s Real New York Pizza in Longmont! I have been driving up there for pizza since they opened. I always am greeted like a friend when I walk thru the doors. My favorite pizza is the Taste Of Italy. Unfortunately I have yet to try it on a sicilian but I will. I also like the Grandma pies as well as the new spicy Calabrian. I like to come in on fridays because they have bagels which makes for an awesome breakfast sandwich. I also like the bread they bake on site. I get one of those and an order of meatballs and make a meatball sub with about half of it and make a breakfast sandwich with the other half. I use to be a thin crust only person but was introduced to Antonio`s sicilian and I am now a big fan of that as well.

Was excited to try this location as I think the location in Estes park is one of the best places to get food in Estes. Their location in Estes is huge as well so it is a perfect spot for bringing family and chilling in the mountains.This location was for sure a lot different. I picked up my pizza to-go so I didn't have the same dine in experience that I have had at the Estes location but it was probably for the best. This location is much smaller and going more for the typical little Main Street authentic pizza place vibe. It seemed a lot more hip and modern (besides the waiter robot at the other location hahaha).I got the white garlic pizza and an order of the garlic knots. Love garlic obviously hahaha.The garlic knots were maybe better than the ones I get at the Estes location but for some reason the pizza didn't hit as much for me here. It was still amazing and better than most pizza places but something felt a bit off from it. Maybe it just wasn't as fresh as when I dine in (obviously).This place is still worth the trip if you live close by or if you don't want to drive to Estes but it doesn't hold up to the original location yet.

Not 'real New York pizza'New Yorker born and raised, this is not New York style pizza. Perhaps the altitude affects the crust? That being said the pizza was mediocre as far as generic pizza goes. Main Street has other pizza options that are much better.Edit: Wish your pizza was as flavorful as your response, Antonio. If you can't take an honest review, maybe you should move back to Ronkonkoma. Putting down Rosalee's is low class. Trashing other local business is unnecessary and makes you look bad as the new kid on the block.

Been waiting quite a while for this!First week so they're just doing slices for lunch. Staff is young and learning but it is very clear they have the basics of pizza dialed in. The crust is the best I've had in Colorado hands down. It's basically perfection. I tried 2 slices of thin crust and one Sicilian with sausage. I don't usually care for thick crust pizzas but with how good Antonio's dough is, it was excellent. Light, fluffy and so flavorful. If you want to grab a few slices there is nowhere better in the area.The atmosphere was great with a steady stream of people coming through. Everyone asked what pizza was what in the case so I'd recommend adding a little sign next to each pizza identifying it to eliminate this. Other than that, the presentation was very inviting. Seating is good for a quick lunch but I can see dinner becoming very crowded, especially once word gets out about how good it is! I'll post another review once they are fully operational and making full pies. Maybe I'll get one made by the man himself.Until then, they are doing great stuff and I was very pleased with my visit. Amazing addition to Longmont!9/10 WILL BE BACK.

What a fun place! My kids loved watching them hand toss the pizza dough, and the staff is very friendly. I had the Colors of Italy pizza, which is a lovely balance of ricotta, pesto and tomato. Yum. I love the crispy crust. My family split the margherita; it had very high quality ingredients. I'd have preferred a bit more cheese, but you know me, I always want more cheese. I'm that kinda gal. My husband liked it the way it was. Overall we were very happy and will be back.

Ok... I admit it, my wife and I are pizza snobs originally from NJ. We read about Antonio's recently so had to give it a try. Let me tell you, this is 5 star legit NY/NJ pizza. We had both a thin crust and Sicilian pies to try. Everything was right. Got to meet Antonio... what a nice guy that does it right. I do not understand the poorer reviews. Not sure what they were looking for, but we've found the goto Friday night pizza joint even though it's a bit of ride to Longmont from Erie. You need to give this joint a go.

Stopped here today and enjoyed it! We ordered a whole pie of the Sicilian and a slice of margarita in the thin crust. They pizza was solid- they don't have the same menu offerings as the Estes location was hoping for wings/garlic knots that I saw on the Yelp page from that location. The crust and the pepperonis were a 10/10 and the sauce on the thin crust was amazing!The service was so/so I asked a few questions and didn't get any enthusiasm or guidance on menu choices- the menu doesn't describe the difference between grandmas style, Sicilian etc. and I personally wasn't familiar.I'll be back- next time I'll do a full pie of the thin crust and maybe figure out what grandmas style is. Overall great addition to the area

Nice spot to stop in for a quick slice of pizza. Great pizza, nice staff, easy prices. Lots of space and good vibe!

As a New Yorker, I was looking forward to Antonio's. The vibe walking in gives NYC pizza shop, but a lot roomier. And the service was quick. I got a cheese slice just to try it out. The thin crust had that beautiful crunch you'd want, but the slice wasn't very flavorful unfortunately.

Longmont is lucky Antonio picked us for his second location. I can vouch it's authentic Long Island Pizza. A nice addition to Main Street joining the other top 2 pizza places in town. Lots of different varieties to try that others don't offer. Check it out!