Anthony's Pizza and Pasta
Anthony's Pizza and Pasta
NY Style cheese slice
Sicilian pepperoni slice
Dining Room
Thin thin thin
I cut mine in half lol but slices ate large!
White Thin Crust Slice Pizza
No pepperoni
NY Style cheese slice
Neapolitan with artichoke, garlic, and fresh basil. Sicilian with jalapeño and pineapple.
Smallest wings ever
Wrong order received & No help
3 Mini Cannoli
Mac and Cheese
Toppings
Neapolitan Thin Crust
Buffalo Boneless wings
Chicken Alfredo
food, tacos
food, pizza
18 inch pepperoni pizza. White Thin Crust Slice Pizza
Cesar Salad
Chicken Wings. Hot/Spicy
Pepperoni and sausage pizza slice
Pepperoni sausage pizza
Lee W.
May 8, 2024
I've heard mixed reviews about Anthony's Pizza & Pasta but I was craving pizza so I gave them a try & it was good! Being originally from NJ (15 miles from NYC) you might think I've gotta have the NY style pizza but actually I grew up on Sicilian pizza. I'm always in search of places that make Sicilian & Anthony's does - plus NY style, Neapolitan & White. They even make Artisan Cauliflower & Gluten-Free. You can order by the slice or pie. The restaurant is cute with a black painted open ceiling, giving it an industrial vibe. There are both tables & chairs or booths to choose from. Taking up almost one whole wall is a framed collage of recognizable NYC photos. It's very cool. To name a few there are pics of Central Park, Time Square, Statue of Liberty, even yellow taxi cabs & of course pizza! We went on a Saturday, mid-afternoon & were the only ones there. We placed our order at the counter. The employee was friendly & brought our food to the table. My husband had the NY Style cheese slice (foldable) & really enjoyed it. I had the Sicilian pepperoni & it was a large slice. The crust was delicious. However, I would have liked more sauce & cheese. We plan on trying some of their other menu items next time. They have sandwiches, salads, pasta and a good assortment of desserts, even limoncello cake!
Read More
Star B.
Oct 12, 2023
It's a good flavor but it's waaay too thin. I'm from the east coast and I LOVE A NY SLICE !!! But here... its like you're eating fried cheese. You can barely fold it. Because it's too flimsy ...they must roll out the dough too too thin. This spot use to be super duper good.. they're kinda falling off. Ima give 3 stars for their customer service and their support for the military! And for that I'll try them again .. Maybe dough is chef specific..
Read More
Sam L.
Mar 28, 2023
Went here despite the low reviews bc I was staying at the hotel in the plaza. I had a slice of the pepperoni and a white pizza and was surprised at how good it was - was a thin crispy crust that reminded me of NY. Their garlic powder seemed to lack a little flavor - maybe it was a bit old. If it wasn't for that I would've give a 5 - try this place out!
Read More
David M.
Dec 5, 2022
Just went there today as i was on a layover. Had a craving for pizza so u thought I'd give it a shot. I got 2 slices with mushrooms, a small farmers salad(best thing I ordered) and 6 bone in wings. Pizza was burned and no flavor. I want to taste the pizza sauce and it had no taste. The wings were THE POOREST excuse for wings I've EVER SEEN. Like you guys really charge for wings this size? Embarrassing
Read More
Zac R.
Feb 3, 2025
Yelp won't let me delete this review so I would like to clarify that Anthony's Pizza remedied this situation very well. I was accommodated for this mishap and my experiences at this location have since been excellent.Thankyou. And Yelp.... you suck for not letting me delete my review! Thanks.
Read More
Mary K.
Oct 15, 2024
They won't answer the phone.... pizza ordered for 6:45, and now they say it will arrive at 7:30. We ordered from the DU franchise. They continue to be bad at delivery times and customer service. I guess the college students keep them in business. I'm out.
Read More
Jeff G.
Jul 18, 2024
We are out visiting from California and the New York Style Pizza (pepperoni & cheese) and Baked Zitti were outstanding. Glad we stopped in!
Read More
Curly ..
Jul 22, 2024
The sub was like target, it was okay but it had no flavor . If someone gave me this and I took a bite without looking I wouldn't know it was a chicken parm...These mozzarella sticks taste like they came from the freezer (Jon tafer would be ashamed ) when I took a bite the cheese wasn't cheesing it wasn't being stringy it was just a bite smh
Read More
Emilienne U.
Jul 15, 2024
Got it Togo and it was empty when we picked it up. Despite average reviews we tried it and it was amazing and we will definitely be returning
Read More
Katana M.
May 26, 2024
Ordered the chicken Alfredo with breaded chicken and the noodles/alfredo was not tasty at all. I can get more flavor from a box of pasta from the store in all honesty (I'm really not exaggerating). Luckily the chicken and bread was quite good. I stopped eating the noodles and only ate the chicken. I also had an appetizer of mozzarella sticks and those were tasty as well. Maybe it was a bad batch but my boyfriend and I both didn't enjoy the noodles/alfredo. I expected the food to be a lot better than it was overall. The service was fine, server didn't really bother us which was nice. There was no line and we got our food in approx 15 ish mins.
Read More
