Anthony's Pizza and Pasta

I went out of my way to pickup a pie here, rather than at a more local pizzeria because I remembered enjoying slices from other Anthony's years ago when I spent most of my time in Longmont.The pizza here was ready when I arrived and was presented with a smile. The store appeared to be clean and tidy.Alas, the crispy-crust 18" pizza was soggy with a very bland thin red sauce and toppings. There was far from a generous amount of cheese, and what was there slid off slices when I separated them.I found myself regretting that I hadn't bought a fresh pie at Costco or a frozen one at Safeway.

Had a catering pick up, ordered 24 hours in advance and when I show up to pick up the order - they say we just got the order. Give us 10-15 minutes.... Been here 20 minutes and no update. Order from the one off Quebec, I have never had an issue with them.

The pizza was GREAT! Annet and restaurant staff was amazing. The Alfredo sauce was terrible and blue cheese dressing. We did take out and everything was hot! Would order pizza again, probably not anything else (specifically pasta). The restaurant looked clean when we picked up our order.

Ignored the star ratings and tried to be hopeful. Worst decision. Quite possibly the worst pizza I've ever had. Was barely cut and the toppings and cheese were barely staying on the undercooked dough. A 5th grader making a pizza lunchable would've probably been a better use of $50. At least then the overall microwaved/undercooked texture would be expected. Have been to quite a few Anthony's... quite a few times. It's always pretty thin, NY-Style pizza. This was closer to a Domino's pizza in thickness. Made it through eating half of the pizza before the thought of the possibility of getting sick from it being undercooked could be held off no longer. To quote what I told to my fiancé - "If didn't need the calories right now.. would throw this up". Anthony's again? Maybe. This location? Couldn't pay me $50 to return.

Overpriced weak pizza...Ordered an 18" supreme, $38.07÷8 slices=$4.75 a slice before tip???Pizza was small wanted to grab a tape measure, pretty sure they gave me maybe a 16"However, website says you can only order 12" or 18"Toppings were normal amount for a pizza, not $3.00 per item worthy.Pizza was soggy, crust was soo thin it couldn't help but be soggy (more toppings will make crust soggy, especially paper thin crust)The one star is for the staff, they were great answering the phone and at pick up.The product is garbage and ridiculously overpriced.

We've been ordering from Anthony's for twenty years. Recently, however quality of pizza haas declined & service is awful. I was told 45 mins for delivery & it was almost two hours. I understand about staff shortages, but why offer delivery at all if you're this inefficient? We won't be back.

We were a little skeptical about the place since we were the only customers at about 6:30pm but we gave it a shot. I also get nervous when people of a different race work and make the food of another race, but I was way off at Anthony's. The pizza was great. I wanted NY style and this was it. If I'm ever in the Denver area again, I will return. The 18" pizza was a little pricey but well worth the price because there were plenty of toppings and it tasted so good. Slices were very large and it appeared to be larger than 18". The only other item we got was mozzarella sticks and they too were excellent. I have nothing bad to say about this place. I usually don't tip much when ordering my food at a counter but the woman working was very nice and I liked the food so much that I left more cash in the tip jar on the counter.

Seven bucks for these meatballs is outrageous! The only reason I'm giving this three stars is because the rest of the food was good..

This place is great. Consistent quality and freshness. I highly recommend the Neapolitan with its perfectly foldable slices. YUM!

70$ for 2 pizzas and 3 drinks better be really good. However, the thick crust pizza tasted artificial and the thin crust pizza was greasy and was difficult to eat as it fell apart. The worst pizza I have had in a very long time.