Atlanta Fish Market

I went in July 2024 with my sister, we ordered the seafood platter for around $50 and it was the best seafood I've had in a loooonnnggggg time! While I am not from Atlanta (I'm from New England), their seafood rivals ours tenfold. Everything was aromatic, fresh, and smelled amazing. I enjoyed the seafood accompanied by buttery mashed potatoes and vegetables. The service was amazing and allowed for online/separate bills. The restaurant decor was beautiful and upscale, I saw a couple of guests come for a more business-type meal and some families coming with their grandparents and kids. This place caters to a wide variety of audiences!

Craving seafood? Lots of options here! I tried the crab cakes based on a recommendation and very fresh! I also added blackened shrimp (4/$16 hmmm). No one can ever say the food is not fresh! I did enjoy my meal. Had the twice baked Asiago potatoes which are red skin. I also had the spinach. The spinach needed a little more flavor.As for ambiance. I expected a little more being in buckhead but it was reminding me of an upscale diner. My sever was very prompt and had good recommendations however I went a different way. She was always there checking on us as well! Overall good experience.

Enjoyed a great meal with coworkers at the Atlanta Fish Market this week. We had reservations (12 people) and were seated promptly upon arriving, no need to unnecessarily wait around.The waiter was quick to get to our table greeting us very excitedly. He was definitely an added benefit to the meal, making jokes and adding lighter every time he stopped by the table. Our drink order was taken quickly, followed by orders for some appetizer sampler trays and then our meals. The drinks and appetizers came out quickly, and as we were finishing those pic the entrees followed behind them. The seafood appetizer platter was amazing, with breaded and fried shrimp, calamari, crab cakes and deep fried lobster tails. I've never had deep fried lobster tails, but like all things,m fried, they tasted great!Having already started to get full, I only ordered a 6oz filet, and that was a fantastically tender cut of meat. Tasted amazing and the mashed potatoes on the side were a great pairing. Word of warning the space is basically one big open room, so if you have trouble hearing in crowded spaces, this may not be a great option for your group to dine at. For our party though, everything tasted great, service was wonderful, and everyone left full. I'll certainly return if I get back to Atlanta again

Really cool Buckhead restaurant. Overall we had a wonderful experience for my wife's birthday. Valet parking mandatory- $3 plus tip. They're highly efficient and great at getting people in and out. The food was excellent with many traditional seafood options. You can pretty much choose your favorite fish and have it cooked anyway you like it. The service was great considering how busy it was. They got my order wrong but I rolled with it anyway. I could tell by the servers reaction that sending it back would've been a problem for her, so I settled with gladness and enjoyed. She did a great job keeping up with us and her section. Huge lines and a packed place for good reason. The unsettling part was the air conditioning wasn't working on a 90 degree June evening. When you're paying top dollar for this kind of experience it's fair to expect a bit more. Great restaurant. I will certainly consider it again.

I recently dined at Atlanta Fish Market and had an overall okay experience. The server was super nice and very hardworking, which was a definite positive. Additionally, the prices were reasonable, which was a pleasant surprise.However, I was a little underwhelmed by the Chilean sea bass. While it was good, it didn't quite wow me as I had hoped. The service also took a really long time, stretching our dining experience to 2.5 hours. This was quite exhausting, especially considering we had a large party.One aspect that was a bit disappointing was the lack of gluten-free options, particularly for appetizers. Unless you're a sushi fan (which I'm not), there weren't many choices available.Overall, Atlanta Fish Market was good but didn't quite live up to my expectations. It was a decent dining experience, but there wasn't anything that stood out as exceptional.

Are you ready for the 411? Here we go...I am in Atlanta for a conference and visited this restaurant. I was so in love with the aesthetic and how much it reminded me of New York. The New England clam chowder was tasty but was just ok...but I would have it again so try it. The jumbo lumpy crab cake was delicious and the string beans perfectly cooked. I am still trying to cook string beans like that. The dessert was AMAZING and I was not disappointed at all by the bread pudding. If you don't try anything else...GET THAT! As always it's about your taste and not mines so definitely try it and share your feedback.

Basic and bland. Service was slow. Sushi was trash. Lobster was watery. Order was incorrect. The crab stuffing taste like tartar sauce and bread.

Went here with people who hadn't been here in over 25 years, and they said it's even better than it used to be! Food was really amazing, including the lobster roll, cashew crusted swordfish, half and half cocktail, and most of all these crab legs. Prices are very fair for what you get, and service is tremendous. An older establishment that has kept up the great food.

We showed up shortly before close and the staff were all so kind and still provided full service. They were attentive and had great recommendations. The crab cakes were to die for!! You must get them!!

This is always been my go to place for fresh seafood. Today's visit doesn't change that opinion! It was our birthdays and my friend and I went to eat lunch there. Dennis,, our server has been the best server since I've been going there for over 20 years!we ordered the golf shrimp and she ordered the clam chowder with the wedge salad. Both were excellent! Daniel surprised us with a really nice birthday dessert! He was extremely attentive, and was good in suggesting ideas! Will definitely return again, and again!