Antipasto Salad
a person holding a slice of pizza
Grandma's Square
a plate of pizza rolls and a bowl of tomato sauce
Garlic Knots
a person taking a slice out of a pizza box
a woman holding a stack of pizzas
The Butcher
pizza, food
drink
pizza, food
Pizza soup
The Butcher's
interior, sushi and sashimi
interior
pizza, food
interior
soppressata
food, pizza
ribs, food
chicken wings and fried chicken, food
Short ribs & Kimchi
sushi and sashimi, drink
Soggy mess
Katherine F.
Aug 17, 2024
Lovely pizza and fun atmosphere. We really enjoyed our pizza here. The Sicilian style makes a nice change from thin based pizza and they have a great selection of toppings. We had the four cheese, mushroom, Texas brisket, kimchi rib and buffalo chicken. All were great! We ate in. It was lovely and clean.
Read More
Shane S.
Nov 14, 2023
Based on reviews, I'm going to go against the grain here a little bit. This is NOT anything like a NY Sicilian pizza. The crust is not buttery, the dough lakes taste and the sauce is unenjoyably spicey. With minimal cheese, it was just bland dough with spicy sauce.The garlic knots felt more like Parmesan dinner roles which were also accompanied by this over-spicy saucy. They were flaky and buttery which just felt off for a garlic knot.
Read More
Grisel A.
Apr 9, 2024
Not sure I'd say Chicago style It was ok. I may have to go in person since I ordered delivery.
Read More
Lilly L.
Aug 21, 2024
Very yummy! Great location if you want a budget friendly place to eat dinner before the Winspear. We really liked every slice we had.
Read More
Gigi T.
Nov 24, 2024
This place was okay. I've seen a bunch of videos hyping this pizza shop, so I decided to go try it. The inside was nice. Service was good, and the pizza looks aesthetically pleasing, but unfortunately, the pizza did not live up to the hype. I've had my fair share of this style of pizza. The sauce reminded me of a spicy lunchable marinara sauce, and the dough was kind of chewy and soft. I would not be returning.
Read More
Samra H.
May 30, 2024
I had the fingerling potato and onion pizza and the texas brisket pizza. I liked the brisket one. The potato one was ok. I think it could have used some more seasoning as it was kind of bland. The pizzas are cut into square and by the slice. I think they are good portions for the price.
Read More
Rich S.
Mar 19, 2024
2/4/24 via DoordashQuadruple Cheese (12x18)(Fresh Mozzarella, Asiago, Pecorino, and Parmesan) - plus added Sausage.SIGH... too much bread, STILL not enough cheese. It's similar to a deep dish or Pan-styled pizza.Fast prep and delivery though; Sauce was good!I attempted to order from here during their advertised first week, but they weren't ready. I'll consider visiting in the future to investigate ambiance, but i won't have the Pizza; maybe side dishes?Their photos look so good, and menu options sound even better. If you're not a pizza snob, I'd say give them a try!I imagine parking is terrible, based on their location; there might be limited street parking or garage parking that could be possibly comped or even valet. Not sure. See other reviewers.
Read More
Sara H.
Sep 1, 2022
Pretty good! First time here and I will say we really enjoyed the the parm garlic knots. The red sauce that comes with it is super spicy but super delicious! We tried a slice (square) of grandmas square and wild mushroom, both really good and full of flavor. I personally thought they were super heavy but I usually like thin crust pizza and this is far from that. Note - this is located inside Sloan's Corner!
Read More
Lee S.
Jul 5, 2023
Parking was atrocious and it's in a busy Dowtown area. This might slightly adjust to a more manageable factor in cooler temps, but now.....nah. The pizza itself had very interesting options and you can customize slices which is dope. Kimchi on pizza is AMAZING. Nothing about the service was standout, but the service style and physical layout minimizes a high degree of interaction. Think Subway on layout. I'd definitely revisit. On a side-note, a side of sauce cost about as much as a slice which literally made LOL. Nice filling slices and cheaper than you'd imagine. I think they have daily specials, as well and a reasonable walk to a nearby park. Do with that what you will ;-).
Read More
Julia B.
Mar 3, 2025
Pizza was overly salty, texture was too dense and seemed like it had been made then reheated. The garlic knots, which had a ton of rave reviews, were disappointing and had the texture of rolls from the frozen aisle. Staff was friendly, order was ready promptly, and restaurant was clean, but overall product quality was lacking.
Read More