Flat bread with Italian butter. A must have.
Pesto chicken panini
Pork Tenderloin
Prime rib
Half of the meatball sub
Here's the receipt
Fillet mignon
Cannoli for the grand finale is a must.
Bread pudding
Manhattan pizza
Other half of the meatball sub!
Wild boar spaghetti
$8 for this slice of cheesecake. I don't want to know how much for a pizza never coming back.
Just awesome
The Greek Pizza is amazing
Tuscan Chicken Pasta, incredibly delicious.
a cup and saucer
grilled seafood, food, fish, seafood, grilled fish
food
salads, salad, food
interior
Order up
interior
Tara M.
Dec 30, 2024
This place is truly a hidden gem, and a real hole in the wall that has some amazing high quality food. The inside is charming with cute tablecloths and a clean environment. I waited inside on a to-go order and was offered a glass of water while I waited which was appreciated. Our order was promptly prepared and it was very good. The salmon was on point, and my pasta dish was very good. The only thing I could not recommend is the cheese bread. It's a bit lack luster. Give it a try, it's one of the better Italian places close to Watauga
Read More
Mariah A.
Jun 25, 2024
This place is truly a gem! They were a bit busy when we walked in (a good sign), we ordered a meatball sub, and the manhattan large pizza.The woman who brought our order out was so nice and welcoming.The meatball sub- WOW! It was massive. This was the best I've had. Nothing was lacking. The sauce and meatballs were amazing! They cut it in half for me and i ate it the next day. Was full each time.The pizza- whew i could have ate a large by myself! It was sooo good, my daughter loved it. And my husband couldn't stop raving about it. This place was a 10/10!! Can't wait to try other menu items.The place is small but cute, would make for a great lunch or dinner vibe.
Read More
Marianne N.
Jul 1, 2023
Holy WOW! I've lived here for years and never came. Was doing laundry at the new laundry mat next store (my king size comforter) and took my kids here while we waited for it.We got many things! Nothing was a disappointment.Let's start with my pesto chicken panini....moist! Flavorful! The homemade bread was amazingly seasoned. I asked for no fries and a small caprese salad on the side. LOVED EVERY BITE!!!My son - that never eats his meal - raved about his spaghetti and meatballs. I tried a meatballs and WOW!The fettuccine Alfredo was magnificent!The pizza we got half NY and half cheese. We did ask for extra sauce and it was PLATINUM!Holy WOW! The place is clean, quite and the staff was GREAT! It's got a cute Italy vibe.
Read More
Jeff D.
Mar 12, 2024
Great chef, could easily start up a high end restaurant if she wanted too! The other reviews are old but I can say that the food is phenomenal!
Read More
Frank O.
Nov 19, 2023
The food here is incredibly amazing I highly recommend NY Pizzeria to anyone wanting to try truly great food, I drive one hour from home on a regular basis just to dine here.
Read More
Josh S.
Aug 13, 2023
Lets be real for a second: if you are a restaurant and you are still in business for decades, you are doing something very well!I have owned all manners of businesses and grew up in the food industry. I have owned a pizza restaurant. I tried them for the first time a few weeks ago and have been back three-(3) times. The pizza has amazing cheese and sauce and it is just really above and beyond the national chains. I asked for mine well done and it was a perfect stand-up crust and no flopping in the hand. The pasta and stomboli was fabulous. It may look like a dive from the outside but we all love great dives. Give it a shot and I think you, too, will be a repeat customer.
Read More
Marielys C.
Apr 7, 2023
They were very welcoming. But only a slice of cheesecake is $8. I don't want to know how much for a box of pizza. I rather go further down where they have great customer service, great food and great prices.
Read More
Zach C.
Sep 13, 2023
Excellent! They catered lunch for our company and did not disappoint. Pizza delicious, salad fresh, cheese sticks on point. 10/10 recommend.
Read More
Carla N.
Aug 12, 2023
Enjoyed the pizzas that we got. Not sure I would call it New York style pizza. Will purchase again.
Read More
Jerry H.
Nov 21, 2022
Wow. Had a special calzone custom order. One of the best in 10 years I cannot wait to go again.
Read More