My New York Pizza

Convinced that not a single person in there has ever been to New York because that tastes worse than Little Cesar's. We came in to get "pizza by the slice" as advertised and they scammed us saying that they don't do that because they weren't going to make a pizza just for individual slices. Our only option was to spend $12 on their smallest pizza. They tried to sell us bottled water and when we refused and asked for water cups and they charged us $1.50 per cup with no ice (which was definitely tap water) and the cups were dirty inside. Pizza itself was disgusting. The crust was hard but the cheese was rubbery and just slid of the pizza like it wasn't even cooked with it. They took forever to get us our order and it was a bad experience overall. We come to this strip mall all the time and NEVER see anyone in there and now we know why. Such a shame cause it could be so good. I wouldn't come back here even if someone paid me to.

Great pizza and great atmosphere anchored by a new FULL bar! This is one of my favorite pizza spots. Don't let the surly man behind the counter scare you away. His pizza is awesome! This last visit we also had Lasagna, tasty, but too soupy for my taste. I'll probably stick to pizza.

I try & try with this place. I try with different names and number because I've had to complain before, but keep trying because there a small business that's close to home. They're just like, lazy acting... my food always feels & tastes old. I ordered a fresh, new, large pizza. It came out burnt like it's been there all day and they rewarmed it or like they just over did it. Looked at it & didn't like it, but still tried it & no. It tastes burnt. The Asian lady owner is so rude when I call, I don't even want to call and let them know. Just don't waste your time here, there's better.

Nice, authentic New York-style pizza reminds me of my days growing up in Brooklyn. This is one of the few places that actually makes NY pizza. If you really want to experience how Brooklyn Pizza is supposed to taste, from the ability to fold a slice to the amount of oil, definitely give them a try.

Blew in because our usual pizza spot closer to home was closed Mondays, so we thought we'd give 'em a try. And they're really good! So I suppose we have another pizza option for the nearby rotation.We got a calzone and a stromboli and shared each other's. They were huge, and made well, and came out quick enough for "made to order". Of the two, we liked the stromboli a bit more.A fun side thing, I'm a nut for all things 80s, and this couple had the kickin'est deep cut music playin', and I mean italo-disco, Modern Talking, Sandra, Bad Boys Blue... I was VERY impressed! And when I mentioned it, I suppose they appreciated their taste to be recognized! I assured them I thought the food was good too! Haa!!! Anyway, meant a lot to me!Another aside, I notice some of the harsh reviews here make a stink about being unable to customize pizza-by-the-slice. I encourage anyone reading those reviews to realize that's not how pizza-by-the-slice works, the ability to make one huge POPULAR choice pizza and selling it to multiple customers. To ask them for a slice of pizza with a weird request (like no marinara) that nobody else would want, those customers are asking them to throw out out 80% of the remainder of pizza. If a customer wants something nobody else would want, get a whole pizza and don't blame them for not understanding the principle of pizza-by-the-slice. Anyway, just had to throw that in.Anyway, great place!

I don't have enough great things to say about My New York Pizza. They're the best pizza in the immediate area. The Husband and wife owners take pride in their business and it shows. I have to say one thing you might want to try is their Mediterranean offerings. The Husband happens to be from Turkey and that lesser known side of the menu is fantastic.

Always good, friendly and they have a wide variety of food from wings, to pizza, to Mediterranean.

I'm not sure why I've come back here for a second time when the pizza is mediocre. The customer service was so abhorrent I will DEFINITELY never return. I'm not sure if it's the owner but he was extremely rude and seemed like he didn't care for the business at all. Eye rolls and sarcastic remarks and snooty comments for no reason at all. I would be surprised if he didn't respond here with some unprofessional response as well. Just felt the need to warn others to take your business elsewhere to someone who appreciates there customers especially when they have done nothing wrong to begin with. Cheese bread has no flavor and the pizza is just okay.

Some nights there is a bar full of customers, and about 8 beers on tap, and some vino. Thankfully there is also a few tables and booths to sit at.

Says their open and OPEN sign is lit up and everything but doors are locked, notices in doorway, not sure what they say... no one answers the phone and no one is inside.