All Too Well

Awesome sandwich spot for a quick and easy lunch! Menu is so full of incredible looking craft sandwiches that it's hard to make a decision. The sandwiches themselves are actually pretty big too, so if you're looking for a light lunch you can split with someone and still be satisfied. Staff is very friendly. Looking forward to returning to try more!

overall this is a solid 3.5 for me, but with lack of half stars i'll go ahead and do four. i've been meaning to try this place for ages as it is on my bike ride home up Lincoln from my gym. finally decided to stop in today. fun selection of sandwiches, and i enjoy that it is a small menu vs a gazillion options. went for the 'bombay chulet' as i really love some sweetness in my salty sandwiches and i am a fan of spicy food as well. got it to eat at the restaurant along with a topo chico. wait time was very short considering it was right at lunch time, however it came in a to-go bag and wrapped. but that wasn't a big deal. the sandwich tasted good, but it was a bit difficult to discern all the flavours and the spicyness from the chilli crunch wasn't too hot sadly. i did add some extra hot honey that they have available on the table that spruced it all up a bit. price-wise: this is pretty pricey for a sandwich, but not uncommon in chicago for similar experiences (e.g.: TriBecca's (which i love)). so i'd go back and try some of the other sammys. the space is cute but can definitely use some paint and cleaning especially for the walls. and the service was fine. a typical young kinda apathetic/uncharismatic person for front of house but generally helpful enough. i guess that's about as much as we can ask for these days. ‍lastly -- no alterations to the sandwiches -- which i don't have a problem with, but i assume many will. i kinda appreciate it generally, though it can limit options. would go back.

Tried these Sammie's and they were def tasty. We went with:- Bombay Chulet- I Make You LambThey were both good, the lamb def had the edge but it was a bit greasy so the chulet was the lower cal of the two. Good portion, pricey but typical for fancy Chicago sandwiches.Overall we would come back but wouldn't go out of the way for it.

I can't wait to keep coming back to All Too Well to try all the sandwiches! The Boatwich was very good. Service was extremely nice and helpful and the atmosphere was just a cute sandwich shop. Loved it!!

The name is a coincidence to the Taylor Swift song but it definitely creates a great vibe. I tried the week special which was amazing and my friend tried the CK1 which used to stand for Catching Kelce :) The sandwiches were fresh and made to order. The take the order and get it to where you're seated since you maybe sitting in the middle of the bench.

My friend and I stopped by over the weekend to grab a bite before a stroll through Lincoln Park. Most people ordered for takeout, but there are some seating options inside the shop. My friend and I both got the Bombay Chulet which was so flavorful and unique. I loved the sweet, salty, and spicy flavors wrapped into each bite. I came here for the nod to T. Swift, but I'll be returning for the sandwiches :D

I had been eyeing this place and saving it for when my Taylor swift fan friends visiting and I wish I came here sooner because it was AMAZING!The interior is pretty small and low key - you order at a counter and there are picnic table and small circular tables to sit at. The food came out so fast. It's the perfect casual space for stopping in for lunch. I also really appreciate how large their water station is - some restaurants make it difficult to stay hydrated and I appreciate that they are prepared!I got the Artie B's (prosciutto, salami, marinara, pesto among other things), my friends got the "oh yeah" sandwich of the day (capricola, Turkey, burrata, lettuce, banana peppers, etc) and the Bombay chalet (turkey, aoli, spicy fig jam, chili crunch, arugula, etc). We tried each others and absolutely loved them all. The bread and ingredients were super fresh on everything and all the flavors perfectly balanced. We agreed the oh yeah had the best balance of freshness and the Bombay chalet had the best sauce. Everything was incredible I will absolutely be coming back because I want to try everything on the menu.

This is 10/10 best sandwich I've ever had, this is my new favorite I got the I make you Lamb, the lamb and chimichurri melts in your mouth and the hints of the whipped feta combined with the provolone for texture these sandwiches are pure poetry, the food came out really quick and the cashier was extremely nice. I love that it has a sign that says no substitutes or mods they know how to make a sandwich why mess it up it's a cute little shop with good decor can't wait to come back.

Got out of an afternoon showing at the Music Box and a sandwich sounded really good but everything on Southport was full already so I convinced my 5 friends to take a Sunday drive over to Lincoln Park so they could give All Too Well and/or Evette's a try. I had tried their Sheffield and Westwood sandwich before and liked it and I remembered they had a pretty big menu so I had a feeling they would probably have something for everyone. The hunch paid off. Each person was able to find something that sounded good to them and they all liked what they ordered. I had trouble deciding between the Bombay Chulet and the I Make You Lamb but luckily one of my friends was kind enough to suggest we order both to share. Just as I finished putting in my order for the lamb with the friendly cashier they called up someone to grab theirs and I was immediately excited by how tasty they looked. There was a good amount of seating available inside and outside if we split up our group but we decided that since it was a nice day we would hoof it over to the park which is a very short walk away to enjoy our lunch there. We sat on the benches and unwrapped our sandwiches and I was greeted with a lovely aroma. I can say without hesitation that the I Make You Lamb is one of the best hot sandwiches I've had in some time. The seasonings on the shredded lamb go great with the whipped feta, chimichurri, and onions. It was so good I felt the need to break off little bits so that my friends could all get a sample.The Bombay Chulet was good too with its spicy fig jam, turkey and prosciutto. Others in our group ordered the Tatanka(Buffalo chicken), Brothers(veggie option), the Boatwich and even falafel wrap from Evette's and everyone really enjoyed their choice. The menu is a little on the expensive side but if it's a quality sandwich with creative touches in terms of flavoring then you have to give All Too Well a try.

Really delicious sandwiches, pretty overpriced in my opinion. They're delicious though and in a prime spot. The CK1 (steak sandwich) is unreal, I had to come back and get it again. The turkey sandwich was great too, you can't go wrong.