Alfy's Pizza

Fresh food, deliciously prepared pizza and clean facilities! With excellent service and a beautifully kept salad bar! But... Four stars due to staffing. They could use another employee during their busy hours.

I understand some people have bad experiences at any restaurant so I discount random ones that talk about a bad employee. Every restaurant has a few bad apples. You gotta excuse all restaurant reviews for the covid years 2020-21 as well. Times were tough. More importantly: How's the food? The service is something you have to judge after a few times. I've been here a few times now for our monthly meetings on Tuesday night. The pizza is okay. Not fantastic but I've had much worse at other places. We get a discount on pizza when we have meetings as does any regular group. I've had the parmesan wings before and they were delicious! I recommend them highly. I like the salad bar. They have lettuce and spinach. I have never noticed bad lettuce in the bowls. They have a ton of goodies to put on your salad. You can have a one time plate or a all-you-can eat plate. It comes with free garlic bread. It's under warm lights so it can get hard after a while. The little ones might like the games they have inside. There are some free old style computer monitors that have some games on them. Some of the monitors dont work though. There's plenty of comfortable seating. I like this place for a family outing or a group meeting. There is a large separate room that can be divided in two sections for smaller groups. Give it a try. The employees have always been friendly. I'm sure you'll like it! I'll take some pics next time I go.

OMFG I GOT FOOD poisoning the pizza sucks so much the cheese is not covering most of the pizza this place is trash

If I could do zero stars I would. Here's how the experience went for us. Keep in mind, we've ordered from Alfys in Monroe on and off for over 8 years now at the same house. 6:30 order pizza. Was told it was not busy, so it would be 30 mins. COOL!8:00 rolls around, no pizza. I call back. They tell me there is a system issue screwing up the tickets making delivery difficult, driver had to return to alfys for address verification. But he is back out. Ok...stuff happens. 8:30 call from the driver with the address ave vs dr. cannot find the house. I give him the correct address. am told I am out of delivery zone, as he continually repeats my address incorrectly. I give him the entire address, surrounding directions, cross street etc. Okay hes on his way again. 9:00 he calls, repeats a COMPLETELY Different address not even close to mine, takes 5 minutes to find the ticket that he says he finally found. I repeat no, this is my address. again with directions, etc. He sounded completely out of it, impaired in some way. But said i'll get yours out to you ahead of my other deliveries.9:30 rolls around, still no pizza. We call the number of the driver for a 3rd conversation where he says I'm off the clock. We say seriously? We've been waiting OVER 3 HOURS WITH NO PIZZA! He says well We're closed. Go F*** yourself. After shock and what just happened arguing with him, he says it again and hangs up. I immediately called Alfys in Monroe vs his cell and a man answers. He says, we're closed you will have to call tomorrow. I said well I would like to make a complaint about one of your drivers. He says Yep. You dont like the way I treated you, go F*** yourself too! I reply with excuse me? And again he repeated it followed with, we dont want you as a customer. I can honestly say I'm shocked. This is the most HORRIBLE customer service situation I have ever had. What the heck is wrong with people. I ordered pizza as a treat for my kids . They were excited about it after a long drive, and yet nothing comes and we are talked to like that? I will be going to Alfys myself tomorrow to have someone make this right as we prepaid. and I will NEVER order from this establishment again. I would rather drive myself than give them a cent of my money.

One of the last Alfy's left and we love making the drive. They still have Nintendo 64 games and my husband and I always get a few games in while they bake our pizzas. The pizza recipe is consistent with what I remember from my childhood. They have a nice banquet room in the back to rent as well, definitely a gathering place for families. With that being said, please make sure your kids understand how dangerous it is to run in here. A lady almost dropped a pizza on a kid because two kids were roughhousing and running through the middle of the entryway/ordering area. The staff is always pleasant too, be sure to stop by!

Friday deal, two medium pizzas for $15 in total! Server super nice and wait time was quick. Came here forThe nostalgia and it didn't disappoint!

So the woman behind the counter is very friendly making a not that great food a favorite but the older man behind the counter is the complete opposite very unfriendly. The pizza toppings are delicious but the crust is mediocre ( albeit better than the cardboard box dough of Dominos thin crust). The salad bar is a plus & you can play Minecraft on Nintendo video games inside parlor.

Love the salad bar here, it's always a treat! Highly disappointed in the way my sister was treated!!!! Garlic bread is part of the salad bar. Purposely made us wait 35 min to get the garlic bread out. It was a disgusting display of customer service. Alfys has struggled enough now this guy is making it worse. Sad!

Alfy's has THE BEST blue cheese dressing hands down !! The pizza is really good but honestly it's just a vessel so I can get as much blue cheese down my throat as possible in one sitting. Fucking amazing.

Really good pizza. It came hot. The cheese is delicious and the crust, I think, is the best crust I've had. Clean restaurant. Very nice place