Pie-O-Neer Pies

I can't say enough about this gem of a restaurant! The service was absolutely fantastic--our server was attentive, friendly, and made us feel right at home. But let's talk about the food! The pies are out of this world, with rich, flavorful fillings and the perfect flaky crust. We tried the turkey pot pie, chocolate chess, coconut chess, and honey pecan. They were all great. And the homemade rolls? They stole the show! Warm, soft, and so delicious, I could have easily made a meal out of those alone. If you plan on doing both a meal and dessert, definitely come hungry. This place is a must-visit for anyone who loves great food and exceptional service!

So I was on my way to Truth or Consequences New Mexico. Yes that is the correct name of where I was going. Saw this huge sign on the road that said, 'Stop'Now I took this not as a warning but as a suggestion. I went to this restaurant and saw the most Delicious pies on display. It was very cozy and quaint inside. Much like all the establishments in New Mexico I'm noticing. Well, I had a multitude of choices I decided on the blueberry. I waited till I got to my hotel and had it after my steak dinner. It was the most delicious pie I've ever had.

What do you expect when you come to a wide spot in the road called Pie Town? Me - stop with any cafe with Pie in the name. So we did. Long motorcycle ride, about halfway around a loop and needed time to get out of the saddle,eat and quench the thirst. We entered a building probably out of the 1930's knickknacks galore and historical pics of the town in the 40's. Small menu board at the counter - only 4 items to chose from. Chicken & green chile pot pie & a slice of coconut cream pie. A generous slice of pie was served 1st. Sweet & topped with toasted coconut it was delicious. 1/2 way thru it the pot pie is delivered. Pot pie is hot, nice brown crust and a good sized amount of green chile on top. No it doesn't compare to anything I've eaten before. Not much broth in the middle. Instead loaded with slices of chicken, cheese & chile. Comfort food at its finest. It was a lot of food - couldn't finish my dessert or entree. Cost was on the higher side. But again large portions and it was a meal - not a snack. Out of the way, wide spot in the road serving up a great meal.

Pie Town, NM is one of those places you could miss if you blink. But keep your eyes peeled, because this fabulous little pie shop is worth the stop. Fabulous, homemade pies. Sunday supper is fun and unique, and at the whim of the chef. Don't be in a hurry. Just relax and enjoy some pie.

My students and I visited Pie-O-Neer Pies during our summer school session of June 2024. My coworkers and I brought 7 middle school students. Sara and her wonderful workers Isabel, Irene and Heather were all so patient and kind to our students. We enjoy their pizza and the students were able to each make their own mini 6inch pie. We all went home with different slices and 6in pies as well. Trying a variety of types, peaches and cream pie, New Mexico apple (with the secret ingredient of green chile), chocolate cream pie, triple lemon cream, cherry pie and Las Cruces pecan pie. I truly enjoy all the memorabilia hung inside the cafe and how much pride Sara takes in her cafe the pies and caring for her customers and staff. Worth stopping in when driving through New Mexico on Highway 60. We also got the pleasure of meeting the Infamous Paul of Pie Town.

Super good pies, I stopped by on my way to go camping in the Gila, picked up a 6inch snickerdoodle and a slice of strawberry lemon. So tasty and love the sweet tea. The walls are decorated with pie town history which was fun to read while I waited. Highly recommend.

Our family stops in here every 6 months or so as we visit relatives in New Mexico. First off, you walk in and the decor is everything! It is country eclectic with a very homey feel. The staff is welcoming and even remembers our family when we stop in.The pies... oh the pies! there is always a wide variety of homemade never store bought (there is not a super market within 50 miles of this place) pies. You will not be disappointed when you stop in for a quick bite or a leisurely afternoon. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND PIE-O-NEER.

Eating pie shouldn't be a political experience, but like so many things in our society today, apparently it is. They're entitled to their political opinions, and we're entitled to take our business elsewhere. Never did get to the pie part.

Always wanted to have pie in Pie Town and the trip didn't disappoint! Everyone I talked to consistently said that all the pies were good - so pick whichever sounds yummiest to you. My friend had the New Mexico Apple with (lots) of ice cream. I ordered the Lemon Blueberry Buttermilk. They were both amazing. Portion sizes are very generous - ended up having to box up what we couldn't finish. Also bought a slice of the Peach to go for my friend who couldn't make the trip.The atmosphere is super cute and folksy. Lots of local goodies available for purchase. The owner was very friendly and we struck up a wonderful conversation when things slowed down enough for her to chat.

Really good chicken sandwich! Fresh and tasty!Got a variety sampler of the pies, husband said the Apple was the BEST he has ever had! Trust me when I say he had tried a whole bunch of apple pies, this one is absolutely TOPS!!! Stop in and try for yourself!!!