Molly Butler Lodge

It was a good overall experience. You know you're kind of limited with choices but we didn't have any like big issues. We went twice for dinner during our week stay. One night with reservation and another we walked in, waited about 5-10 mins each time to get seated and or even approached. We meandered to the bar and just waited till it was our time. Food was on point. Of course I got the prime rib, don't even remember what my wife got cause we actually went like a month ago as of me writing this.... Anyway, the RANCH was fricken great. Wasn't that thick commercial ranch, home made and great. Drinks were great, view out on the patio was great. It was good. Four stars cause of the walk in night it took forever for someone to greet us.

Reservation only, not open until 5pm for dinner. Sadly didn't get to stay for dinner without this info ahead of time, starving and hardly anywhere to eat in this little town.

Hands down the best prime rib Service is always top notch A go to special place for us

We had the pleasure of dining at this quaint, rustic, and fun restaurant this past Labor Day weekend. There were 16 of us and we were able to get a reservation. Let me just say, the food was good and the hospitality from Sandy and her staff was phenomenal. My nephew recommended this restaurant from a previous visit he had. From the huge fireplace to the delicious wings and roasted Brussels sprouts with sweet potatoes, everyone enjoyed their meals.Sandy thank you for your warm and welcoming customer service and great food. We will definitely be back next year!!!

A MUST when visiting Greer! My husband and I had our engagement dinner here 3 years ago and just recently made it back for another visit during the wintertime to see SNOW. This time with our new baby in tow! They've remodeled it since then and it is pretty snazzy now. The bar area is a lot smaller but the dining room is rustic and more trendy. All in all, it is a super cozy mountain eatery with great drinks + eats. The food is always a treat. I LOVE their Molly cut Prime Rib with a baked potato. It is some of the best Prime Rib that i've ever had and you can't go wrong with a yummy baked potato. I ordered a dinner salad to start and their ranch dressing is Hailey-approved (i'm so picky about ranch but Molly Butler does it right). For dessert we got the mud pie and while I don't think they make it in house (I could be wrong) it was still pretty tasty! We also had the friendliest hostess + server ever (I wish that I remembered their names)! Anyways, this is a Greer classic and we can't wait to come back again soon!

Truly a staple on the mountain. My Husband and I visited Molly Butler at the recommendation of a family member. Our first time here as we just moved to Show Low. It won't be our last! The ambiance alone would draw us back along with the views. The food and customer service round this place out as one of our absolute favorites. We tried the Caesar salad (best dressing ever!), Buffalo wings which were saucy and still juicy while being crunchy. My Husband got the side of chili which was EXCELLENT and the Rueben: everything was really great. Did I mention the AMAZING spicy bloody Mary's?! We can't wait to go back!

Not many lunch options in Greer. Big place but they must be understaffed as tons of tables left open. Dining room to the right had 13 tables with diners at just two of them. Tasty Bloody Mary. Chili was great. Salads were very good. Service mediocre, they really didn't come around much to refill drinks or see if anything was needed.

If you're a person of color, I wouldn't recommend eating here. Molly Butler's opens at 5 pm for dinner.... we arrived at 4:50pm and were told it would be a 15-minute wait. Unfortunately, after an hour and a half, we finally left. It was so upsetting to see them keep sitting Caucasian and us still waiting when we were told we would be sitted in 15 minutes. Shame on you, Molly Butler in Greer AZ.

Excellent Dinner on a special Saturday Night. Great service and great atmosphere.Outdoor patio is a beautiful view of the area Highly recommend reservations

My buddies and I came here on a trip last month. This place is wonderful. They sat us right at their lunch hour ended (I know, terrible thing to do, we felt bad but they were kind and insisted on us). The food was awesome, I do not remember what I got (just that I liked it) but my friends let me try their French dip (9/10) and wings (10/10). As we were headed out, they let us sign the wall, which I do not believe is a normal thing but my friends and I will remember it for all time. While my friend carved, I saw the mud pie and realized: I needed one.As a result, we decided to come back 4 hours later just for deserts. Mud pie was to die for, of course.Perfect experience, cannot wait to come back!