Margarita pizza
GoodFellas
Huge Pizza Slices!
a pizza on a table
Goodfellas is the bomb. Great tasting Calzone!!!!
Hot Buffalo Wings!
Menu
two pizzas on a table
Pepperoni pizza
food, pizza
Chicken pizza. Notice what's missing?
food, pizza
Burnt garlic knots covered with cheese after I specifically asked for none This was part of my replacement
Meatball sub
pizza, food
Menu
food, pizza
pizza, food
food, chicken wings and fried chicken
Should have been a margarita pizza not exactly meets the description
Ahhh...The Start of Another "Good"fellas Day!
Chicken wing
Visit us today and see why we are the "Home of the Humongous Slice!" Please like us on at Facebook.com/goodfellasnm
pizza
Judy V.
Dec 28, 2024
Excellent in every way they follow every instruction! I don't care for their mozzarella sticks, but they're deep dish. Well done is freaking amazing! And there Cobb salad salads are amazing. Everything is amazing here.
Read More
Kenneth H.
Nov 25, 2024
These people hire teenagers who don't care... Their quality of service and food is not good... Microwave food and and just hurry up and order attitude... No adult supervision... Surprised that they are still in business...Guess The Name Says It All...Goodfellas Will Rip You Off... Fast Food Italian A Place To Avoid...
Read More
Angela B.
Jun 27, 2024
New York pizza in New Mexico? Yes, at GoodFellas. The crust is chewy and delicious, just like an East Coast pizza should be. Toppings are fresh and generous with plenty of cheese. My son had a calzone and devoured the whole thing before I could get a single bite. It was easy to order over the phone and our pizza was waiting for us when I got there. They called us back with a question about our order, which I appreciated. Everyone was friendly and you can tell it's a family business where they are happy to welcome you.
Read More
Honey S.
Mar 15, 2024
Hand made pizza mom and pops style restaurant. Dine in area great for get togethers. Family oriented business.
Read More
Bella B.
Sep 2, 2022
Traveled down yonder south to small town Los Lunas and checked out Goodfellas.True and authentic NewYork style pizza handcrafted by Frank aka Franky the Pizza Boss, was great to meet him as he is a hardworking and true to his love & passion in bringing the best pies to Los Lunas. I'm not trying to be a wiseguy but Goodfellas is whipping out some of the best Pies in town, along with their super duper stuffed calzone delicious pizza rolls and definitely has some finger licking good wings and their creative twist of a Greek style pizza! Mamma Mia Goodfellas you've stolen a pizz-a my heart!
Read More
Darryl N.
Mar 12, 2024
Great Pizza. I don't have no complaints on how it's made. Every ingredients Goodfellas puts in their pizzas in awesome. Especially "The Soprano" which my favorite with what else....green Chile.
Read More
John B.
Apr 25, 2024
Ford is outstanding! Slices are huge. Good New York Style Pizza. Why does this have to be so long.
Read More
Daphne B.
May 30, 2021
I would love to be able to rate the Pizza Higher but honestly my tastebuds are blown out due to the overwhelming heaping handfuls of garlic. The pizza description lists a lot of wonderful ingredients but I can't speak to the taste of the house made sauce, homemade mozzarella or dough. I can confirm that the pizza I received was void of fresh basil. Three of us tried to eat this and no one could get through a single slice. Hopefully the deserts are better, will try them tomorrow. I hope this isn't the norm here was really looking forward to some decent NY style pizza. Tried to call the restaurant but they kept putting me on hold and hanging up before I could talk to anyone.
Read More
Elaine L.
Jan 19, 2025
Pizza, wings and garlic knots are always amazing. Workers are always friendly and food always comes out fast.
Read More
C S.
Jun 8, 2024
This used to be one of my favorites. The owner is great and hardworking. The new staff and the quality of food has gone down hill.. last time I was in I waited almost an hour for a to-go order while I watched others come in after me and leave before me. No I didn't have a large or complicated order.
Read More