Church Street Café
Church Street Café
Best on rye. White breast of turkey, Swiss cheese, and green chile.
Best on a french roll. Shredded top round roast served with a side of our own special red chili dip.
Best on whole what. Thinly sliced lean ham with melted cheese.
Best on a sourdough. Ham, turkey, cheddar cheese, Swiss cheese, bacon, lettuce and tomato.
Best on a baguette. Avocado, lettuce, sprouts, cucumbers, tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers, and cream cheese.
Best on a croissant. Grilled zucchini, sauteed onions and bell peppers, tomatoes and cheese.
Best on a four tortilla. The classic sandwich served in a new way with green chile.
Best on a flour tortilla. Tender chicken breast grilled with cheese and green chile.
Best on marble rye. Hot corned beef served with Swiss cheese and sauerkraut (Green chile optional).
Vegetarian patty with cheese, guacamole, lettuce and tomato, served on a sesame seed bun.
A 1/4 lb. lean beef patty with cheese, lettuce and tomato served on Indian fry bread.
Same as Pueblo Burger but served in a fresh tortilla.
Green chile in a melted cheese sauce served with tortilla chips.
Frito chips smothered in beef and beans with your choice of red or green chile.
Cubed pork, fried and served hot with a fresh tortilla.
Tortilla chips, melted cheese, salsa, guacamole, beef, beans, and sour cream.
Spicy avocado dip on a bed of lettuce with yellow corn tortilla chips.
Shredded beef rolled in corn tortillas served with sour cream and guacamole.
2 types of melted cheese captured between a four tortilla . Add beef or chicken for an additional charge.
Beef tripe served with white corn and your choice of red or green chile.
White corn served with marinated pork and your choice of red or green chile.
Red, green, or vegetarian chile served with meat and/or beans.
Choice of grilled cheese, turkey, ham, ruben, maries vegetarian, or grilled vegetarian.
Choice of grilled cheese, turkey, ham, ruben, maries vegetarian, or grilled vegetarian
Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, black olives, and sprouts served with choice of dressing.
Ham, turkey, cheese, tomato, cucumber, and egg slices with mixed salad greens.
Assorted fruits (in season) served with yogurt or cottage cheese.
Hand-formed four tortilla shell with crisp lettuce, tomatoes, seasoned beef, salsa, shredded cheddar cheese, guacamole, and sour cream.
Marinated sliced charbroiled chicken breast or sirloin strips atop mixed salad greens and garnished with cheddar cheese, avocado, tomatoes and black olives.
Dried cranberries, raisins, bleu cheese crumbles with mixed greens garnished with fruit and nuts in season. Add grilled chicken for an additional charge.
Wedge of iceberg lettuce served with bleu cheese crumbles, bacon, and tomatoes.
Fresh spinach, tomatoes, bacon, and egg. Add grilled chicken for an additional charge.
Strips of sirloin steak or marinated chicken, sauteed onions, and bell peppers with your choice of red or green chile on the side.
Portabella mushrooms, bell peppers, and sauteed onions.
2 fresh vegetarian or pork corn tamales hand prepared and smothered in your choice of red or green chile.
Oven-cooked pork marinated in red chile.
2 large green chiles stuffed with cheese dipped in egg batter and fried.
Made the old Spanish way with meat and cheese, lightly dipped in egg batter, fried and topped with green chile.
2 enchiladas (flat or rolled) smothered in your choice of red or green chile on corn tortillas.
Flour tortilla filled with potatoes, chicken, seasoned beef, beans, or carne adovada then smothered with red or green chile.
1 tamale, 1 chile relleno, and 1 enchilada with red or green chile. Add beef or chicken enchilada for an additional charge.
2 fried eggs on a bed of frijoles (beans) and blue corn tortillas, a side of papitas and covered with your choice of red or green chile and smothered in melted cheddar cheese.
A 3 egg cheddar cheese omelette with your choice of ham or bacon ( for meat), extra cheese, bell peppers, mushrooms, onions, red or green chile for an additional charge.
2 scrambled eggs with bacon or ham rolled in a flour tortilla and topped with your choice of red or green chile and smothered in melted cheddar cheese.
2 eggs with choice of bacon, sausage or chorizo served with toast and papitas (fried little potatoes).
Bacon and 2 eggs (any style) smothered with chile and cheese piled on top of a mountain of papitas.
2 pancakes plain or with fresh blueberries served with 2 eggs (any style) and 2 slices of bacon.
Sauteed strips of sirloin served with 2 eggs (any style) a side of papitas and your choice of red or green chile.
Oven-cooked pork marinated in red chile melted cheese on top, a side of papitas and 2 eggs (any style)
2 scrambled eggs, cheddar cheese, chopped green chile and your choice of bacon or ham on a flour tortilla.
Granola or oatmeal with your choice of plain or flavored yogurt served with freshly sliced fruit.
Almost big enough for 2.
Old town favorite.
Mexican pudding.
Blueberry, chocolate and lemon cranberry.
Fry bread dusted with cinnamon and sugar.
Egg custard with caramel.
Served with vanilla ice cream.
Sopapillas dustedo with powder sugar
Fajitas
1/2 lb. Fajitas
Blueberry-Lavender Dream
Caramel Cafe Latte , with ice requested
Front of the restaurant
Front of Building
a colorful gazebo in a small town
a margarita with a slice of lime on the rim
Entrance
Front entrance
interior
the entrance to a mexican restaurant
The Historic Interior
interior, paella
Back great room
Prickly Pear Margarita
outside
Love the interior
menu
interior
tacos, outside
Howard B.
Nov 1, 2024
If you eat anywhere in Old Town & want great atmosphere, Mexican cuisine, fantastic service this is your place. We went in on Halloween day, Aron greeted us with a smile. He took us back to our seats as we got to admire all the Halloween decorations. I ask Aron about the history of the building, he was very knowledgeable on place. That the building was built in the early 1700's. Being one of the oldest buildings in Old Town. He gave us a pamphlet/menu that had wonderful information on it about the long history of this building. Ask him about the lady buried in the floors when you visit, that was a great story.Cafe was clean & spacious. Waitress Shelby was quick to get out drinks, take order, & answer any questions about menu/food available. I ask if I could take pictures for this review she said yes, then showed me the great room & courtyard.The food was plentiful, hot, delicious, & green chiles perfect. She gave us the option to have the sopapillas with meal or at the end. We chose at end. She brought them out hot with a honey bottle, they were outstanding. I highly recommend this cafe, you will not be disappointed. We will definitely be back. FYI: there is no parking out front, so you will need to park in the square or around Old Town. There is no place to park a large RV, but there are fee parking areas with in the area.
Read More
Kevin P.
Dec 14, 2024
The food is fantastic !!!The atmosphere is great !!The service is absolutely terrible!!!!
Read More
Monica F.
Oct 26, 2024
Oct 2024 Food and service was great! Request chips and salsa if you like. But I did not find it in essential to the meal. This is the oldest house in Old Town and it is beautiful and supposedly haunted. The haunted tour I took later led right to this restaurant. It's clear this place is special.
Read More
Kami S.
Nov 12, 2024
I give this place 3.75 stars. The atmosphere is great, the frozen pitcher of prickly pear margarita was the best I had in all of New Mexico, and the price was right, 5 stars! We were also seriated by a local band and that added to the fun!The food was ok 3 stars, had the fry bread green chili cheese burger with kinda sad fries and chicken enchiladas. Both were fine just nothing to write home about.
Read More
Stephanie C.
Sep 25, 2024
This is definitely a must try if you are a tourist or a local! For me, I would say they serve authentic New Mexican food :) You can't go wrong with chicharrones for an appetizer! They always come out hot and fresh with tortillas and chili. Going on a week day, I was surprised to see it packed. Service was on the slower side but it was expected because of the full house. You can't go wrong with sitting outside. They have a beautiful established patio with a waterfall, beautiful decor and stunning greenery.
Read More
Victoria P.
Nov 25, 2024
Like any other review, please take this one with a grain of salt lol I only ordered hot chocolate here lol We were in Old Town late in the evening and NOTHING was open. It was cold, we went to see the tree/lights, and were craving hot chocolate. This was the only place open around 7 pm at night. We went in and ordered 2 hot chocolates. It tasted like Abuelita hot chocolate with a dash of Chile powder, extra cinnamon, and richer chocolate. It was delicious and hit the spot! So in reality, we did not order food, but rather only Hot Chocolate. Service was great. The workers made conversation with us and did not make us feel like a bother. Old town was very quiet as was the restaurant. So if you're in the area and craving some hot chocolate - I recommend visiting Church Street Cafe!
Read More
Liza M.
Apr 25, 2024
Oh my goodness! We had the best waitress! I loved how she sat down with us to see what we wanted for lunch. I went with a friend to try out a new place and we were not disappointed. The beans and the potatoes and the chili!! Everything was delicious. The natillas for desert were a wonderful reminder of my childhood. The atmosphere was fantastic! So much greenery and flowers made for a wonderful time. Inside was much bigger than I thought it would be.Old Town can be tricky for parking but so worth it. It's located behind the church and I promise you, you won't be disappointed. Nice local restaurant! I will definitely be going again!
Read More
Maithili S.
Dec 7, 2024
Food was just ok. We got the green chile chicken soup and the huevos rancheros. There was live mariachi that was entertaining. Conveniently located in old town.
Read More
Chris R.
Mar 16, 2024
First time at Church Street Cafe. The location is very cool with dining areas woven throughout an adobe structure dating to the early 1700's. We started with the chili con queso. The queso was mild/medium heat but I couldn't really taste the chili. It tasted more like a processed cheese sauce than anything unique. The chips were homemade and crispy. $12 is a bit much for this quality. My entree was chicken tacos. The meat was tender and moist with chunks of white and dark meat, cheese, lettuce, and tomato to accompany. The bean and rice were not very flavorful and I had to eat the tacos with a fork because the tortilla couldn't handle the amount of liquid from the chicken. Good flavor but nothing special. My partner had the vegetarian combination plate. One major positive from the menu is many vegetarian options. Her combination plate included chili relleno, enchilada, tamale, and calabacitas. The food was average in flavor but we truly appreciated the vegetarian options. In conclusion, Church Street Cafe is a beautiful building with many vegetarian dishes of traditional New Mexican food. Unfortunately, the food is average at best and there are probably better options nearby in beautiful old town.
Read More
Mike B.
Feb 24, 2025
Service was ridiculously slow, took 30 minutes for us to get water! We couldn't get chips/salsa refills to save our lives!!! The food was just OK but the salsa (the very small amount we got) is outstanding! Very disappointing all around experience.
Read More
Rated: 4.3 (243 reviews) · $$
Mexican, Seafood, New Mexican Cuisine
