Cake Fetish
Cake Fetish
The Drama Queen
three cupcakes on a wooden table
three cupcakes on a wooden board
Lemon cupcake
three cupcakes on a wooden table
two cupcakes on a wooden table
a vase of roses and hearts on a table
a table and chairs in a restaurant
the interior of a bakery
food
food
Hours
food
food
interior
food
food
food
Priscilla S.
Mar 2, 2025
Cake Fetish is one of our favorite places to get cakes! We've ordered here a few times. Their Chantilly cupcake is always a must have bc it is consistently so moist and yummy. This visit, we decided to try 4 cupcakes. I asked the attendant of they used artificial dyes. By the uncertainty abs hesitation in her response, I'm guessing yes. So, I avoided anything colorful, like their mint chocolate. We opted for the Chantilly, Shaundalin Bday, Double Chocolate, and Cookie Dough. I'll be honest, I didn't feel as impressed with these cupcakes. I guess they seemed a little dry compared to the past. The Shaundalin Bday is a Ginger cake, lime butter cream, and ginger pipette. We were intrigued by the presentation and the name bc it's the owner's creation. It had good flavor, and the mint and lime adds freshness. It was balanced, but dry. The Cookie Dough had the Cookie Crisp cereal on top, and some inside the cupcake, and again tasted dry. I wished it had actually Cookie Dough bc I didn't really like it. I didn't try the other 2 bc my kids are them. Overall, not a wow experience as I'd hoped. But I definitely recommend their mini cupcakes! Always such a treat to grab a half dozen or dozen. Their buttercream also doesn't disappoint. I also tried their ganache on a cup cake from another event, and it was so good!
Read More
Jen C.
Feb 19, 2025
Came in on an overnight. Bakery opens at 10am. I grew up in a bakery and helped out for many years, so they always peak my interest when traveling.The selections of cupcakes were plentiful. Overall I enjoyed both cupcakes I got (a colorful buttercream on chocolate and strawberry), but the strawberry maybe tasted too much like a box mix for my liking. I know a lot of bakers use a box base, no shame, but it needs more of a deviation from that flavor for me.The gal behind the counter was helpful enough, but what stood out for me was how cute the bakery was decorated for Valentines Day. I appreciate the nice touches like the neon sign and having a table reserved for maybe a tasting? which really told me the owners appreciate and welcome their customers far more than hourly staff. Wish I would have gotten the multi mini pack and tried more flavors. Definitely will try more on my next overnight.
Read More
Heidi A.
Feb 28, 2024
Lemon cupcake is soooo good. It's to die for. I love the frosting as well as the lemon curd inside the cupcake
Read More
Meagan L.
Sep 3, 2024
I've gotten some cupcakes from their pop-up in Tin Can Alley! They're good, a little dry, though that might be because I've only gotten them towards the end of the day. The frosting is good but very dense and I tend to like my buttercream a little lighter- not whipped, just less dense. The flavors I've had for both cake and frosting have been very good though and I do try to get a cupcake whenever I'm there!
Read More
Nhu P.
Jan 14, 2023
Delicious dessert place inside do Tin Can Alley! They also have little pup treats too! I got the assorted cupcake box and each cupcake bite was delicious! My favorite was the half-baked chocolate chip cookie one! VERY DELICIOUS! I also liked that each cupcake wasn't too sweet! Can't wait to try there tiger deserts when I visit again! Also my little fur babies loved their treats
Read More
Laura H.
Aug 18, 2023
Best cupcakes I've had outside Magnolia in NYC! Every flavor is absolute perfection!!!
Read More
Cynthia K.
Dec 22, 2024
Delicious and beautifully decorated cupcakes. Unfortunately, the person who filled my order was very rude. I will not go back. The cupcakes were't good enough to make up for the poor customer service.
Read More
Denise C.
Nov 26, 2024
Great service, be prepared for a line. Purchased 6 amazing cupcakes to share with family. Wonderful and unusual, tasty and beautifully decorated. They tasted as good as they looked. We cut them in half so family members could taste different cake flavors. The buttercream was exceptional! Best cake place in town for a special order.
Read More
Haley B.
Jul 9, 2024
Although the frosting was overwhelming, and too sweet, the cake was amazing! I would go back, just for the cake!
Read More
Christen K.
Aug 2, 2023
The wedding cakes provided by Cake Fetish for our wedding were so beautiful and delicious!! Our guests raved about the cake. We ordered extra for our 150 guests and I don't think we had any leftover by the end of the night :-) All 4 flavors were incredible (lemon cake with raspberry filling and lemon buttercream, chantilly cake with berries and vanilla buttercream, marble cake with fudge filling and vanilla buttercream, and vanilla cake with strawberry filling and cream cheese buttercream). We did a three tiered cake with gold drip and fresh flowers for presentation with additional sheet cakes to serve the guests.
Read More
